app-review-board team mailing list archive

[Allison Randal <allison@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

The Oct 25 deadline is only for replying. You can submit an app for
Oneiric anytime from October 13 to mid-April. It's fine to either submit
0.15 now and submit an update for 0.16 when it's ready, or to wait and
submit 0.16. At the moment, you won't get benefits like app stats and
re-reviews of new versions for an ARB app, but new features  for the
developer.ubuntu.com submission portal are coming soon, they might even
be ready by the time you submit 0.16. If the new features aren't ready
when you submit, then submitting a new ARB app through
developer.ubuntu.com will just create a new ticket here, so there's  no
significant difference between the two.

In your PPA, your app does have an Oneiric version of the package, but
if you look at the package details, you can see it was actually built
for Natty:

harmonyseq (0.15-release~oneiric1) natty; urgency=low

The packages need to be built on Oneiric, to make sure they're
compatible with the Oneiric versions of any dependencies or tools used
in building it. So that's the reason for specifying 'oneiric' in the
changelog line. Also, packages for the ARB do have a specific version
format requirement, with "extras" and the Ubuntu release version number
included. In your case, I'd expect the final version to be named:

harmonyseq (0.16-0extras11.10.1) oneiric; urgency=low

But, while you're releasing test packages for review, you'll probably
want to name them something like:

harmonyseq (0.16-0extras11.10.1~oneiric1) oneiric; urgency=low

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of
Application Review Board, which is subscribed to Ubuntu Application
Review Board.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/730196

Title:
  Application Review Request: harmonySEQ 0.15

Status in Ubuntu Application Review Board:
  New

Bug description:
      Application Review For harmonySEQ 0.15

      == About You ==

      * NAME: Rafał Cieślak
      * EMAIL ADDRESS: rafalcieslak256 <at> gmail.com

      The Application:

      * APPLICATION NAME: harmonySEQ
      * LICENSE: GNU GPL v3
      * PPA URL: https://launchpad.net/~rafalcieslak256/+archive/harmonyseq
      * SUPPORT RESOURCE http://answers.launchpad.net/harmonyseq, http://harmonyseq.wordpress.com/contact or email to rafalcieslak256 <at> gmail.com
      * KNOWN ISSUES: https://bugs.launchpad.net/harmonyseq

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu-app-review-board/+bug/730196/+subscriptions