← Back to team overview

hugin-devs team mailing list archive

[Bug 687393] Re: When HDR merging bracketed photos, EXR appears white in most apps

 

Adding an attachment with:
- Source JPG's (created from original NEF files, scaled down with Photoshop batch image processing)
- Hugin PTO and PTO.MK files with control points defined, position optimized, and other settings
- Resulting EXR file (I deleted the intermediate TIFF's.. as the resulting EXR shows the problem)
- Screenshots from opening the EXR in Photoshop, Luminance HDR, and Picturenaut

Note: Observe that Picturenaut is the only program that successfully
opens the EXR, but I am able to re-save the EXR from within Picturenaut
and open that file in anything.

** Attachment added: "Demonstration of bug with source files and EXR output"
   https://bugs.launchpad.net/hugin/+bug/687393/+attachment/1779059/+files/Hugin%20HDR%20Merge.7z

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Hugin
Developers, which is subscribed to Hugin.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/687393

Title:
  When HDR merging bracketed photos, EXR appears white in most apps

Status in Hugin - Panorama Tools GUI:
  Incomplete

Bug description:
  I've been struggling with this for a few days now, and finally decided to log a bug. I'm attempting to merge together three JPG's taken with my Nikon D5000 using bracketed exposure values. I found some tips and instructions on merging into a single HDR, and I think I have the process correct. I was using the 2010.2 version initially, but since upgraded to the latest dev beta, 2010.4 beta 2. The stitching page looks a bit better, but the results are the same.

My process:
1. Load images
2. Set control points
3.Optimize only position / view (the default "wizard" settings mess up the alignment)
4. Optimize FOV / crop
5. Generate "High Dynamic Range Merged Stacks"

So.. I also have the latest Luminance HDR 2.0.2 as well as Photoshop CS4 with the latest available EXR plugin. I also have Piturenaut 3.0 for HDR processing. When I open either the intermediate or the final stacked HDR file that was generated with Hugin, the entire thing appears all white in Photoshop. When I attempt to open it with Luminance HDR, it crashes Luminance.

Fortunately, I found that I can open the generated EXR in Picturenaut and then re-save the EXR from there to process it with Luminance. This is an annoying workaround, but at least it works!

I suspect this is a bug in hdr_merge... possibly to do with the EXR libraries..

Best regards,
-Sean

PS. If you would like a copy of the photos I'm merging, let me know the best way to send them over.

Additional info:
System: Windows 7 Ultimate 32 bit w/ 3 GB of RAM





References