kicad-developers team mailing list archive
Mailing list archive
Re: Eeschema library editor - seperate value + name
Dick Hollenbeck <dick@...>
Thu, 12 Nov 2009 13:05:26 -0600
Thunderbird 188.8.131.52 (X11/20090817)
Brian Sidebotham wrote:
I want to provide a patch to seperate the use of "Name" and "Value" in
eeschema's library editor for a couple of reasons:
(1) It is confusing.
(2) The library format, as Wayne pointed out can support these two
things seperately and indeed eeschema does.
So, I want to add the component Name field to the properties dialog
box, and change the library component save function to use the
component Name instead of the component Value which is already
included in the components property fields.
Before I do the patch, is everyone okay with this or have any other
suggestions, or ideas?
A couple of thoughts are:
Should the value field still be filled with the component Name when
creating a new component, or should I leave it blank? I think filling
it in is confusing (for me), but leaving it blank might leave existing
Also, someone out there might currently rely on changing the value
field to create a new component from an old component. I don't want to
confuse someone into overwriting an existing component because of the
change in operation! So this favours towards leaving the value field
blank. But, perhaps this is reason enough to add the Name textbox to
the field properties dialog instead of the component properties
All thoughts welcome.
I cannot offer an informed opinion at this time. I think you are going
about this the right way, i.e. asking for feedback first. I would give
Jean-Pierre and Wayne sufficient time to comment.