kicad-developers team mailing list archive
-
kicad-developers team
-
Mailing list archive
-
Message #38656
Re: RFC: Moving footprint wizards to github
-
To:
kicad-developers@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
-
From:
Thomas Pointhuber <thomas.pointhuber@xxxxxx>
-
Date:
Mon, 17 Dec 2018 09:48:50 +0100
-
Autocrypt:
addr=thomas.pointhuber@xxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQINBFKxhfoBEADDCVK/vsBRi6BnOVSNa+2+xDQt+rBZt7D7BiTm6vaH/NYh+MFyujViIwIt dducp1y09Bkheqfy1tZVBznAC9L/+scePboOeTRTOMtghp041RXC6K7B4J3RMO0++9XdgDlC KLkNhpyPhb2uKVtGBzZjAPyV9udScv5AnQGrPvE1fIs7CreUPj+sSnRYb0sp5qZRaSpXSmKU NyTFEQtuaR1RXl0Dekj4BfXOr+RBdy8oewvGL64uJYd1ddsJ+uKLURbAZCd4n76g/7y1M+T+ Z0fsO7JT8HPA/4O9FrYHEl6dQTgCos3HsWqqP0xHzW9eR/xTXtNGJ8NSMO11Fla6U27Fb6os XFutSczwkoF3bkhLufodg1y9z+MZ3G5hBidYKRJMxFBLcKqtmcgwfSFI9IP50XH0RY1aOLXJ YsSO/1U+h5LHIYWirLvy6UvWdPD/+cSZgG6JxrHnd/gz0YxzNy8RNo9eGZx34+UTVw6OlKfP CnHvT56Dd9ntRxZ+okKvxSE2/Lc97/xrQj/L1Lgqo6QeHRRmn0V7tAGQR5iYTTVzitjnwGxm St8W4rUJRGdOhpig4r5vy8tZvZ9sJlNkQ2ah1iVTCV1+YBivuKi9EtMCEIoks9AfAPs9iFgl ftmT+5GKq5AA6QuXH9wwlgzJZKQi1UeB4i8RxKnN0De1tINesQARAQABtCxUaG9tYXMgUG9p bnRodWJlciA8dGhvbWFzLnBvaW50aHViZXJAZ214LmF0PokCVAQTAQgAPgIbIwULCQgHAgYV CAkKCwIEFgIDAQIeAQIXgBYhBFeMngIV9HTw3olSRscJ2HTtryVWBQJb8U0eBQkLIPqkAAoJ EMcJ2HTtryVWHhUQAIHo71DWdLPNRnJWAst3plIUqAkomixqKc5utYpPtJLQrjl6bKSk1n/v cGRjGpnWBLtqRnxiwTVdryukCFScqiMM3mHTR+5DL2ftXfNgNPV6TrwShd5YSIIlsmNp++C9 eCtyvoiKH95g7uTbUUbN0NkpOCfl/+94hIjvuNWU0OQ0IBbC7KwPmP4UpH5CB7Pzi8LphPSA P1fRZ3nMgM7+H2jgavWLmTsWrCy53lbodiKII7vQooYoOz7sUntmeNRcbKuBXFyTQEjrQ6UI UoEycHE5zBoGXROnJ5ySYysRl3ZGLrlw//aPT3uwjQunXTTkkBJ5ROwNnWb3HpQNIdp90Icz xdqC06ZNTkMVr+OkNmujhl5f8szATBLzGixmUcDMhkS4Hqmgv3GFt8jT/Q+qVXus7pYl047w qc8msfAQkEBPfnUrYLzNsWeM0zq3P771c36o68ctwasFwMiG2SVkXH48JzZfTjjroP6y4vIi u9CnTG7fEx4fFJBTe1/im1xtMysjCbYY5lwnu0uiGwZMjCaAki80XC+STlLYbRlp0ZjSmUhS o85KRJ/hdIMnUzSXs1BRUM16UymZTbM48w22gBhLKvg5Nkaqib44R9XmFJqCxKVjeNdOQrUE 6XVTgDEB4s5bY+2h3De+gh8fMTTtuiM7I5zufeNNr8M4T9Vn+S3yuQINBFKxhfoBEACrlI5d Uy5YjVGieH3P4G9We26Z33leU8UVl2sL4fxyA3bHC/kPNQRcov3Esd8gQHnSe3BQz5Ei+jNs 1rQxQ1waI66tDePErgJ57HFgwTQs1BotZkqRIiWS2DQ/07kckEF8mD2WrykDP4IbL8J+TOr2 TKwrctdvXxbXSKiYJeg2mC5y9+68lHlyB6l5jTSK3/gV4K/PpnsuGIpbYWPvJGLWkb9coDnD sjL46DwrmEFI5hvvIRreALlN4DBly2Gl1mSPiBV3Z2gwoZHN0hybATE16lw3iQeFCLi2v6ot 2MjWTOh7jwputQTKQ56LAewKENtRSycx4f5OGeXRLv3BMXv/Rl7fWFIvB4xhazzS5idcwyeU jPCsLlwziG2HzN8PbuDBHAIty/usIFUV0Q6+OL0h8IQczqKxFdzg2c5WP2u1Ay0NgWceS1P2 Ck1x4mJH+Hi7UOa8CoidoZ6gqDwm24yL04uU2HlK1qb/aqrNdpfC30dKCPck7OG16CXh5g0q MoJ8owGkDKj5l73CWmvz53jbhO5cPSPeeJJL7kKerG/cZOEtGgyuDGgEHZw2sLI09mYhrXe4 1ioimsRLbjUJzV6G9qmggICPLHxCXUUtPEv0esV/jb6kFBouvXaNUlcgumVt96Msirm1pIxm ebuLWAEtLsamcl0KEX0R87zCPQLl3QARAQABiQI8BBgBAgAmAhsMFiEEV4yeAhX0dPDeiVJG xwnYdO2vJVYFAlvxTSEFCQsg+qcACgkQxwnYdO2vJVZJfQ/+M3gsZFURX0wL2WN9DGfLY/96 Kp1UbD9Ikqt2JY8eZoPjvVyGl5OxUl2TnEdycFeymrGfI5cYZzY1dLg9M6BVLGuTi+TaDcjf 7ZxzoSVJVgTh36f2m1tCsnTgbcCX2kO3TEUecT/kQoABCkAl95sgFZOa1HywSqGVFv78Olx2 r1izacH1AB1z6GWI6D+hdqjIdt1kQu7fDqlmn2Hg7ADYxqJxWas/Nu1tWDjHeZ4tBSFdkGpD Y0qF7w/5KB4rtAPaBXHVKzxxU9CWjUY1DpsS7AEDz1MG6g3Fmgvrx2rD9iockrC58QxzEsbD MlZX5o3BOTt5798Udwn3p4eq2zVEfl7yZJWApbwcZGKwzAq8TGirrPQsR48vKM7lPvENhB0L y0leHiC7haCRpOFfExnhQt+cpI7A9XCBDGSNaUrv6MMRXTFaNz15xEnGsCFUANWLCMiCgunf fsSZg4MAFDTJ05lMtb1pXZrq03wv+6S30pjcaQxO/UEZFmr2t/wL/wqClOF2hsE7GdcEbZfx kmx2tqnbU+kSLSG/6e4KHEVwNg72Ahvmp5DssII/t69VbSzls2C5sUTHeHkOpGN+8gygTjzM ValbSKzBEaJBN9VMkzk2VVDvpo1dTlyqpsMDFtmQfi+tUm4D/bTXvXfNZfNswWMX3yxKFcPW dYhw9pBfZ9Q=
-
In-reply-to:
<955fd5c2-a067-0e15-1ac5-24196b075cfa@gmail.com>
-
Openpgp:
preference=signencrypt
-
User-agent:
Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.3.3
Hi,
I'm in favor of managing the scripts like the library in a distinct
repository, but I would wait after 5.1 release, as well as not simply
copying the existing scripts into that repository.
I made a RFC on the forum some time ago how I would think such a
repository could look like, which would imply that the footprint wizards
are scriptable in the future, as well as they represent the reference
implementation for footprints (which are currently located in my own
repository):
https://forum.kicad.info/t/rfc-future-of-footprint-wizard-and-generator/12592
Regards, Thomas
Am 16.12.18 um 17:54 schrieb Wayne Stambaugh:
> On 12/15/2018 10:42 PM, Seth Hillbrand wrote:
>> Am 2018-12-15 21:09, schrieb Oliver Walters:
>>> Seth,
>>>
>>>> I like this idea. Coupled with a build/install CMake script in the
>>>> repo
>>>> would make iterating on the Python script development faster/easier.
>>>
>>> A cmake script sounds like a good idea, would you be willing to add
>>> this to the repo?
>>
>> Sure. But let's give a few days for any objections before moving ahead.
>> There may be concerns that I'm not thinking of.
>>
>> -S
>>
>
> I'm not sure I like this idea. I have no objections to scripts that are
> not distributed with KiCad to be maintained in any manner the developer
> see fit. I would prefer that any source code that gets distributed with
> KiCad remain in the source repo. I would not be opposed to removing the
> footprint wizards from KiCad and make them a separate project but I'm
> not sure all of our users would agree with installing them separately
> since they have been part of KiCad almost as long as the python
> scripting support.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Wayne
>
> _______________________________________________
> Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~kicad-developers
> Post to : kicad-developers@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~kicad-developers
> More help : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp
>
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Follow ups
References