kicad-developers team mailing list archive
-
kicad-developers team
-
Mailing list archive
-
Message #38786
Re: [RFC] Symbol library file format
-
To:
<kicad-developers@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
-
From:
Vesa Solonen <vesa.solonen@xxxxxxxx>
-
Date:
Wed, 2 Jan 2019 21:55:23 +0200
-
Autocrypt:
addr=vesa.solonen@xxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQGiBEiy9EERBAD82hFx3nitjEVNCtkuedqJkwrBgNRsQIsR4zmT0Oy1okWnkzSRyEZHkesA HQy5d5z1OAGSn8BHEL2tJdQKbOCRhEL21yj35T81euDhD3q7pAxrJwwYz5wAyJpZ6ejMGG/g WOrsn5YpdkpR7RxdQ8GUAf7okUoQDemWNY9F8ftZ4wCg+cTF1WmXVPhzKBwy5GVMpTfQehcD /REoeVu4bwm2wTOQpkbnYdR7jJ8XyaAhZVpciWkrm0EH3ES7WhVDmaXzWb8gThzKjurnth6U s4nV7o9vG06sMDzf2siu/Ugbn/QZ1HW9lw2GeXBxwdSbctKiKOukTGNyb2xHN9upETAh9b6f vhNa0nlk+k4kuzvilMmuFSNFZ23HA/4r6kEfa16uK3oR5GQScvIojo95b3LgY2KsrFD6A0b0 61YLZusEB6gIiZ/DcJ+FQy8hQ6u04AmOOXwrneCfluzJFGhaHwOEJj9jwEQN2JMqgjHuMD+v 99Vph+Lzdm9UGOodPKGJ1JL3YyY9QYHj4IedTmDngJaI/2aRB/pgbB2NZbQkVmVzYSBTb2xv bmVuIDx2ZXNhLnNvbG9uZW5AYWFsdG8uZmk+iGIEExECACIFAlFZRuoCGwMGCwkIBwMCBhUI AgkKCwQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEHdUiFKgf4oRqVYAniu9/5XXglIeOd9v5exITDQXvm+jAJ9C 8EANjzQECWHh2YoE8nziX++VSrkCDQRIsvRGEAgA2v+TJXKtFv5TFtqy2egg0ARXX0i8+LtR tPtsXOCWUN51sSX8/1o23MPSzynMJNOsZ8yMEU7I9dDpEnZLAcaBGNrxj6V69uM1m4aAyds6 Qqwm+/nyBDz0zwQwayQjypqRahNTzH9cjIbXOJElh7otGvfI/8PBKCWzu6t/DjiM2+azFTod ADR8w/VXtSmoz5l+ouqJbHKE3xsNFFWnUbfit3EgGrpq16GYFNKm4+h8DIGyvz4YycB2Dmuo Aq+toOUeiIzH1GYe2pwjVzLVG+8x6kU/DRl7Qzst8P+eX4uMSfdepqUVIvYO00+vvYuL9Dkf qiz2lzhuTy+uUmlwvE8A6wADBQf9FD+wb0OWOlF7rG4f3DmdHmKQIXunFy64khfXh4NnCmJs pOfCQ9I+cw3vTeX9UwOHtBKFgUkt10lXYSoaaf7cXG7pTUTUKuy8IZeVd1e91WYqedTGYo9p I99mPP8q5mQFN4sV/pyYycyx8DREm7VMuprjAsoeZ6db6ZW+oweI6GkztCtXdPl4Ui84FSS/ CbSrXIoG9WkXz5DyHrfcEJpbYPMkY+ISnENlt5od/UdD+QlnqP907EJQhnBnftSmyrGzPx3M zno3kDGBwzbmy7HRBFs4dTfFbgZnp1JJNbfStDtNlbgO3mIeHDG4J6shTNe/Bg2mEauj7I/d pMnflWmkKIhJBBgRAgAJBQJIsvRGAhsMAAoJEHdUiFKgf4oRLjcAn19oVj+nNWXC9SRamlTc Nfp99bByAKD1R/uGemuAaJz3A46tUaEbVQ7Fww==
-
In-reply-to:
<c35e7a4c-7e59-cc2a-e861-a07492b73448@gmail.com>
-
Openpgp:
preference=signencrypt
-
User-agent:
Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.2.1
kristoffer Ödmark kirjoitti 2.1.2019 klo 12.32:
> I would rather have a new atomic file-format or storage format, so one
> could actually send a complete part in an easy way, that would include
> 3D-Files, SPICE data, symbol and footprints, and it would also mean that
> one could do the mapping to pins in that directory or file instead.
>
> And since the discussion about adding a manufacturer part number to
> libraries went nowhere, I cannot see how adding a SPICE model would fit
> here, and if SPICE models are added. Well then I suggest we add 3D-Files
> and Footprints as well, no use in half-assing it.
Agreed. Considering how much has changed (also outside KiCad) since the
new symbol format was drafted it may be worth a second look at the issues.
I would suggest having a second look with Horizon EDA if there is any
common ground as there are certainly only things to be gained from some
cooperation:
https://github.com/carrotIndustries/horizon/wiki/The-Pool
-Vesa
Follow ups
References