mahara-contributors team mailing list archive

[Kristina Hoeppner <1940798@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

** Description changed:

- When comment moderation is turned on, you are not taken to the page
- comment itself any more but are left at the top of the page. Since the
- notification doesn't mention the content of the comment, it is difficult
- for the portfolio author to know which comment is to be made public when
- there are multiple comments.
+ The comment notification email does not take you to the page comment
+ itself any more but are left at the top of the page. The comment has to
+ be searched for on the page if it is a page comment or the artefact
+ found, which can be tricky when there are lots of artefacts on a page.
  
  The URL is something like view/view.php?id=27&showcomment=180 and
  /view/view.php?id=27&artefact=163&showcomment=181 for a comment on an
  artefact, but you don't jump to the comment.
  
  To replicate:
  
  1. PersonA creates a page and includes an image that allows comments.
- 2. PersonA shares the page with PersonB and makes sure that in 'Advanced options' comments are set to 'No'. The comment permissions can then be set for this person individually. Check the box for 'Allow comments' and 'Moderate'.
- 2. PersonA also shares the page with PersonC, allowing comments but not requiring moderation.
- 3. Log in as PersonB and leave a public comment on the page and on the artefact. You see "This comment is private. You have requested that this comment be made public."
+ 2. PersonA shares the page with PersonB and allows comments.
+ 3. Log in as PersonB and leave a public comment on the page and on the artefact.
  4. Log in as PersonA.
- 5. PersonA received 2 notifications: 1) The comment itself, 2) The notification about making the comment public.
+ 5. PersonA received a notification with a link to the page comment and a notification with the link to the artefact comment.
  
  Expected result: Clicking the link in the email that is to take you to
- the comment takes you to the comment.
+ the comment takes you to the comment. In the case of the artefact
+ comment that should open the modal. In case of the page comment, the
+ comment should be seen at the top of the page or somehow highlighted
+ temporarily.
  
  Actual result: The link only takes you to the page but not the comment
  or the comment on the artefact.
  
  A separate bug report is filed for moderating comments.

** Description changed:

  The comment notification email does not take you to the page comment
  itself any more but are left at the top of the page. The comment has to
  be searched for on the page if it is a page comment or the artefact
  found, which can be tricky when there are lots of artefacts on a page.
  
  The URL is something like view/view.php?id=27&showcomment=180 and
  /view/view.php?id=27&artefact=163&showcomment=181 for a comment on an
  artefact, but you don't jump to the comment.
  
  To replicate:
  
  1. PersonA creates a page and includes an image that allows comments.
  2. PersonA shares the page with PersonB and allows comments.
  3. Log in as PersonB and leave a public comment on the page and on the artefact.
  4. Log in as PersonA.
  5. PersonA received a notification with a link to the page comment and a notification with the link to the artefact comment.
  
  Expected result: Clicking the link in the email that is to take you to
  the comment takes you to the comment. In the case of the artefact
  comment that should open the modal. In case of the page comment, the
  comment should be seen at the top of the page or somehow highlighted
  temporarily.
  
  Actual result: The link only takes you to the page but not the comment
  or the comment on the artefact.
  
- A separate bug report is filed for moderating comments.
+ There is bug #1940800 that deals with moderated comments.

** Tags added: usability

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Mahara
Contributors, which is subscribed to Mahara.
Matching subscriptions: mahara-contributors
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1940798

Title:
  Comment notification doesn't take you to the comment

Status in Mahara:
  Confirmed

Bug description:
  The comment notification email does not take you to the page comment
  itself any more but are left at the top of the page. The comment has
  to be searched for on the page if it is a page comment or the artefact
  found, which can be tricky when there are lots of artefacts on a page.

  The URL is something like view/view.php?id=27&showcomment=180 and
  /view/view.php?id=27&artefact=163&showcomment=181 for a comment on an
  artefact, but you don't jump to the comment.

  To replicate:

  1. PersonA creates a page and includes an image that allows comments.
  2. PersonA shares the page with PersonB and allows comments.
  3. Log in as PersonB and leave a public comment on the page and on the artefact.
  4. Log in as PersonA.
  5. PersonA received a notification with a link to the page comment and a notification with the link to the artefact comment.

  Expected result: Clicking the link in the email that is to take you to
  the comment takes you to the comment. In the case of the artefact
  comment that should open the modal. In case of the page comment, the
  comment should be seen at the top of the page or somehow highlighted
  temporarily.

  Actual result: The link only takes you to the page but not the comment
  or the comment on the artefact.

  There is bug #1940800 that deals with moderated comments.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/mahara/+bug/1940798/+subscriptions