openerp-india team mailing list archive

["Amit Parik \(OpenERP\)" <amp@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Hello Dmitrijs,

I have clearly analysed this issue, But I think all are working correct
as per the behaviour.

Now, I explain you the current behaviour of 6.1 trunk according to your
scenario.

First Ravish was described you the SO to PO cycle and your behaviour for
MO to PO. There is no difference in SO to PO or MO to PO scenario for
created PO because the main thing is, here we have consider the quantity
of PO. So that doesn't matter the PO created from SO or MO.

Yes, you are right. We are used a arithmetic rounding for this (Product
UoM 's rounding precision as well as for all rounding).

You can see that we have used different value for rounding precision
field for different  'Product UoM Category' like for kg and gm we have
used 0.010 and for PC we have used 1.00 value. Because for unit type of
categories, I don't think the product 's quantity going in to decimal
value. As well as this field is changeable, So we can change this easily
as per our requirement.

According to your scenario, If you want the PO for 1.111 PC quantity
then you have to change your product UoM's rounding precision as 0.001
then and then only it will satisfied your scenario.

I have attached a video for this whcih is described the solution of your
configuration as well as described that we have used different rounding
precision for different product UoM category.

Now comes your another two problem.

#Ceiling Rounding..

You have suggested that we have to use 'Ceiling Rounding' instead of 'Arithmetic Rounding'. Below some example of Ceiling Rounding.
'Ceiling(0.00) = 0
'Ceiling(0.10) = 1
'Ceiling(0.20) = 1
.
.
'Ceiling(0.90) = 1
'Ceiling(1.00) = 1
'Ceiling(1.10) = 2

But As per my 'Opinion' the  'Arithmetic Rounding' is proper for this
because we have used everywhere this same rounding functionality. But
may be your suggestion is good because If we used a Ceiling Rounding
then always satisfied our required product.

#Why used "Rounding Precision" in "Product UoM"?

Ans:- Currently quantity rounding is consider based on Rounding
Precision field of "Product UoM" object because different UoM have
different rounding as I described above. If our product UoM id PCS then
there is no possibility that our product goes into decimal quantity, I
mean it never possible If I Purchase or Sale 1.12 or 1.5 PCS in real
scenario.

If our product UoM is in KG or Liter then it's possible, that's why we
have consider different 'Rounding Precision' for different UoM.

So as per my "Opinion' this place is better for satisfy the quantity
rounding that's why current behaviour is good.

Finally it's not a bug rather than your suggestion that's why I am
setting it as a "Wishlist"

For last two point I am consider it as an "Opinion" because mainly for
Ceiling Rounding point we need a more discussion then and then only we
can look this issue on future.

@Experts: Would you please share your views on this.

Thanks and more suggestions are welcomed!

** Changed in: openobject-addons
   Importance: Low => Wishlist

** Changed in: openobject-addons
       Status: Confirmed => Opinion

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of OpenERP
Indian Team, which is subscribed to OpenERP Addons.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/915481

Title:
  mrp, procurements: does not round up product qty on order

Status in OpenERP Addons (modules):
  Opinion

Bug description:
  Using v6.0 addons revision 4996 with a demo database
  Using trunk addons revision  6339 with a demo database

  Steps to reproduce:
  in v6.0
  1) create new Bill of Materials with
  in trunk
  1) modify existing bill of Materials with

  - Product [RCK100] Rack 100cm
  - Product Qty: 9.00
  - Components:
     [LIN40] Wood Lintel 4m  x Product Qty 1.00

  = the rest is common =

  2) Create and confirm MO:
  - Product [RCK100] Rack 100cm
  - Product Qty: 10.00

  3) Run procurement schedular with automatic order point ticked.

  Expected results:
  MO consumed products: LIN40 qty 1.111
  PO quotation: LIN40 qty 2

  Actual results:
  MO consumed products: LIN40 qty 1.111
  PO quotation: LIN40 qty 1

  The bug:
  Even when the procurement will be completed there will not be enough stock to consume.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/openobject-addons/+bug/915481/+subscriptions