openlp-core team mailing list archive

[Andreas Preikschat <739994@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

I tested the other osis files (which have been converted for the wizard)
and only found this in the Menge bible.

So, I assume that the Menge osis file is wrong. I try to contact
somebody to fix this.

Cheers

Possible "duplicates":
Gen.2.4 already in the list
Exod.22.2 already in the list
1Kgs.7.18 already in the list
1Kgs.7.20 already in the list
1Kgs.11.25 already in the list
Eccl.2.12 already in the list
Isa.63.19 already in the list
Dan.10.21 already in the list
Obad.1.15 already in the list
Mark.13.9 already in the list
Mark.15.20 already in the list
John.19.16 already in the list
Acts.8.1 already in the list
Acts.9.19 already in the list
Acts.14.21 already in the list
Sir.1.4 already in the list
Sir.1.5 already in the list
Sir.1.8 already in the list
Sir.1.10 already in the list
Sir.1.11 already in the list
Sir.1.13 already in the list
Sir.1.18 already in the list
Sir.3.18 already in the list
Sir.3.23 already in the list
Sir.9.8 already in the list
Sir.10.8 already in the list
Sir.11.13 already in the list
Sir.16.14 already in the list
Sir.19.18 already in the list
Sir.20.2 already in the list
Sir.20.30 already in the list
Sir.25.11 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.26.18 already in the list
Sir.36.18 already in the list

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of OpenLP
Core, which is subscribed to OpenLP.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/739994

Title:
  Splitted bible verses create two search results

Status in OpenLP - Worship Presentation Software:
  New

Bug description:
  Hello,

  I was not sure, how to name this bug...

  As I am not sure, what the solution for this is, I explain everything
  in detail.

  1)The Menge Bible contains Genesis 2:4 twice (osis file [1]), which is why the sqlite for the first time wizard contains Genesis 2:4 twice as well (sqlite file [2]).
  2) First try to search and preview Genesis 2:4.
  3) This may lead to wrong bible verse orders, e. g. try Genesis 2:3-5 with a dual bible. As you can see, the second bible will display its 5th verse on the slide of "the second" part of the fourth verse of the first bible. Which is wrong....

  I had a look at my Luther bible and found, that Genesis 2:4 is
  separated by a title (you know, those title labelling sections within
  chapters).

  The question now is,
  a) is the osis file wrong? To me it seems wrong, that there are two verses with the same osisID (normally IDs are unique). However, the OSIS standard or its documentation [3] is very long, so I am just guessing here...
  or
  b) do we have to take of this?
   
  It would be good, if we could sort at least answer question a) out before releasing Beta 1, because then we can try to fix the databases ourself, before we offer them to the users.

  Cheers

  [1] http://sourceforge.net/projects/zefania-sharp/files/Osis%20XML%20Modules%20%28raw%29/GER/Menge-Bibel/sf-menge-bibel_osis.xml/download?use_mirror=ignum
  [2] http://www.openlp.org/files/frw/Menge_Bibel.sqlite
  [3] http://www.bibletechnologies.net/utilities/fmtdocview.cfm?id=28871A67-D5F5-4381-B22EC4947601628B&method=title