openstack team mailing list archive
-
openstack team
-
Mailing list archive
-
Message #03942
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
On Wed, Sep 7, 2011 at 11:42 AM, Kevin L. Mitchell
<kevin.mitchell@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> On Wed, 2011-09-07 at 11:24 -0400, Jay Pipes wrote:
>> In addition, this doesn't prevent anyone on the core team from doing a
>> straight close and merge of the pull request into trunk, potentially
>> breaking trunk.
>
> So far as I know, there's no requirement that someone have merge
> authority on a project in order to comment on pull requests. Do cores
> have direct access to the openstack repos right now, and if they do,
> what's to stop them from merging pull requests into trunk?
No. Gerrit and Jenkins own the canonical repos, and that's the whole point.
> I think
> cores are smart enough to follow the procedures laid down, and if they
> can't, well, they need to not be cores.
I repeat my previous statement about humans being poor gatekeepers
compared to automated enforceable policies.
-jay
Follow ups
References
-
A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Sandy Walsh, 2011-09-01
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Thierry Carrez, 2011-09-02
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Jay Payne, 2011-09-03
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Thierry Carrez, 2011-09-03
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Josh Kearney, 2011-09-03
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Chuck Thier, 2011-09-04
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Ewan Mellor, 2011-09-05
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Sandy Walsh, 2011-09-05
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Stefano Maffulli, 2011-09-05
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Sandy Walsh, 2011-09-05
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Monty Taylor, 2011-09-07
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Sandy Walsh, 2011-09-07
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Soren Hansen, 2011-09-07
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Josh Kearney, 2011-09-07
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Sandy Walsh, 2011-09-07
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Jay Pipes, 2011-09-07
-
Re: A possible alternative to Gerrit ...
From: Kevin L. Mitchell, 2011-09-07