openstack team mailing list archive

[Brian Schott <brian.schott@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

We tried to register for an OpenStack BOF at Supercomputing 2012 this year and were turned down.  How is OpenStack vendor specific?   Being rejected makes no sense to me considering they had BOFs on BlueGene, Cray XMT, and CoArray Fortran last year.  <grumble> The same 25 people will attend the CoArray Fortran BOF this year and their average age is probably 70. </grumble>

Is anyone aware of any SC12 sessions that we might crash?  Discuss it on openstack-hpc list!
http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-hpc

Brian

-------------------------------------------------
Brian Schott, CTO
Nimbis Services, Inc.
brian.schott@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
ph: 443-274-6064  fx: 443-274-6060

bof214 Reviews Details
Submission: Bridging the Cloud-HPC Gap with OpenStack
Contributors: Pai, Schott, Walters

Key for the below column headings: hide
Review Categories (higher is better):
Goals:	Does the proposal clearly articulate the goals of the BOF?
[Absolutely NO; Probably NO; Probably YES; Absolutely YES]
Fit:	Does the BOF fit with the goal of the SC12 Technical Program? (Demonstrate, debate and discover innovative, cutting-edge advances in HPC, networking, storage and analysis)
[Absolutely NO; Probably NO; Probably YES; Absolutely YES]
Interact:	Does the proposed BOF define an interactive approach?
[Not interactive; Slightly interactive; Moderately interactive; Fully interactive]
Innov:	Does this BOF include a new or innovative idea applicable to technology or policy?
[Absolutely NO; Probably NO; Probably YES; Absolutely YES]
New:	Is the proposed BOF new or a repeat from previous years?
[Repeat of Previous Year(s); Repeat of SC11 BOF; New; Don't know]
Commun:	Is the proposed BOF an “organized meeting” for a community activity? If yes, is this a newly formed community?
[No, No; Yes, No; Yes, Yes; Don't know]
Int:	Do you believe that there will be interest at SC12 in this topic?
[Absolutely NO; Probably NO; Probably YES; Absolutely YES]
Qual:	What is the quality of the technical content of this BOF?
[Poor; Fair; Good; Excellent]
Worksh:	Can the proposed BOF be a small workshop or a tutorial?
[Absolutely NO; Probably NO; Probably YES; Absolutely YES]
Vendor:	Does the BOF define a commercial technology by a specific vendor?
[Vendor Specific; Vendor Agnostic; Not commercial]
Accept:	Proposal Acceptability
[REJECT; NEUTRAL; ACCEPT]



Summary of reviews of bof214s1	
Reviewer	Goals	Fit	Interact	Innov	New	Commun	Int	Qual	Worksh	Vendor	Accept
Reviewer 1	Absolutely YES (3)	Probably YES (2)	Moderately interactive (2)	Probably YES (2)	Repeat of Previous Year(s) (1)	Yes, No (1)	Probably YES (2)	Good (2)	Probably NO (1)	Not commercial (2)	ACCEPT (2)
Reviewer 2	Probably YES (2)	Probably YES (2)	Slightly interactive (1)	Probably YES (2)	Don't know (4)	Yes, No (1)	Probably YES (2)	Fair (1)	Probably YES (2)	Vendor Specific (0)	REJECT (0)
Averages:	2.5	2.0	1.5	2.0	2.5	1.0	2.0	1.5	1.5	1.0	1.0

Commitee Comments jump
Review of bof214s1 by Reviewer 1	top

Comments for Authors:
The presentation will inform attendees of the current state of HPC OpenStack, followed by a discussion between the attendees to describe missing/desired features, state of the art, potential opportunities, etc.

Previous BoFs were very successful.

Review of bof214s1 by Reviewer 2	top

Comments for Authors:
The high-level questions and goals of this BoF are laudable. However, the focus here is purely on OpenStack. Due to the very narrow scope/focus of this BoF, this reviewer does not believe this is "community" enough to be a BoF and should be therefore placed under a vendor program.


Committee Comments to Authors: