registry team mailing list archive

[Bruce R <195483@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

You know an awful lot of nonsense gets dogmatically said on the topic of sound digitisation and this and other related Bug Reports have been no exception to that rule.
Ignoring the inflammatory, not to say ignorant nature of some remarks, yet not yielding to rude bully-boy tactics, I will just make one last attempt to explain.

CD audio digitisation of music is a compromise, originally derived from
techniques used to digitise audio speech over buried copper wires, back
around 1970.

To then recode those results with MP3 inevitably imposes further
limitations on the perceived quality, although 128K CBR coding is found
acceptable by quite a lot of folk who have probably never heard anything
better or who have already damaged hearing.

More discriminating listeners, who may have experienced live orchestral
music or old technology vinyl records and valve amplifiers or even
modern products from the likes of NAIM (who haven't forgotten that it's
user perception that counts) may be hoping for something better.

CD-like Quality, provided that the reproduction equipment and listener perceptions are good enough, is generally recognised to be a better compromise for MP3 re-coding.
On a 'please most of the folk most of the time' basis, 32-320K VBR coding seems to be acceptable, but most disagreement seems to have been  about whether that new compromise is perfectly achieved, without stopping to simply listen to the results.

When I simply stop to listen, 128K CBR sounds 'muffled' to my ears,
whilst different VBR codings impose their own colouration, so it was
with relief I found that Linux Sound Juicer could be modified for
perceptibly better results, rather than using Windows hosted CDEX or
later Foobar2000 as directly recommended by a Hydrogenaudio forum
member.

Using 'Bruce R' profiles I have received some very favourable comments
from my circle of friends and others, including some musicians. However,
the bottom line is that if they report an improvement using a 'KennoVO'
profile, I may re-encode my CD collection for their listening benefit,
but I hope to retain the freedom to make that choice, which is why I was
distressed to have that apparently being desperately prevented, for
whatever reason.

-- 
Sound Juicer - MP3 quality doesn't change
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/195483
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Registry
Administrators, which is the registrant for GStreamer.