rohc team mailing list archive

Thread
Date

Re: Issues with feedback-2 when dropping context on compressor

To: Rohc <rohc@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, "didier@xxxxxxxxxxx" <didier@xxxxxxxxxxx>
From: Yakir Matusovsky <yakir.matusovsky@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Thu, 5 Mar 2020 00:29:48 +0000
Accept-language: en-NZ, en-US
Arc-authentication-results: i=1; mx.microsoft.com 1; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=mimomax.com; dmarc=pass action=none header.from=mimomax.com; dkim=pass header.d=mimomax.com; arc=none
Arc-message-signature: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=microsoft.com; s=arcselector9901; h=From:Date:Subject:Message-ID:Content-Type:MIME-Version:X-MS-Exchange-SenderADCheck; bh=YWauJiFdCvJNMND/zZHh2EipzBmS1Gmwan8lqy+8tSg=; b=lz2QdVSFLfxwFzNU0g7PAKZqC6L2fkg0zoV5LEllgloy+oAn8ilzc/2L8m8oessvjQHk0dMbXo7nd+bIP7qG03kYN96xrZhbATZSJNYTEUjdzfy1aORkipBMF9ozydv92VfTsFt/bPPt9z90/vVidLbBf1wKSzH7P8vIa4ocQtB8RJDcq4xR8jGpSDoL3zTdrZa6QlzzzlwHwip2uUtBtQJS07ddjKWA47hpt9esMMC4BB3gy2lOv2Ac800J5HSKl0tB7JpLoG8BFQkUVmrvesbG7DcDEvkhZUmWQZ817PhnyA/5tnQ8GWUe9USS+5Wlz3oWFyQUp2xiWhR/1k45VQ==
Arc-seal: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; s=arcselector9901; d=microsoft.com; cv=none; b=Ik1TrzA0UV/dPeJHvUK7puyKJNfuIQPlZ810GrfoZHgynxKdM3+NxjVu1nqIguz3w7ONKwoijvsswYEgcNxSmSKbBPqbMwe/qvo04yxMxwRn0/6lH1rSvBYszqSAyL0ZoI1s2Uj5Ra8uwBje6iUYk4VE0MixXKJlmwVtcvupxdFZC9FPCm4y3rYWaeG0A0pfg+pelXUbBnUDNQCZ62864u+6H4rDkUdABqQeMy1jb1JNbWqhyMlU2HHXi2oyYIJWd19bcbs12LRBTcLFn/fXiOVi83JPg5SEjhPbbg+S5ASoVGXq44LlG4QfHsNabOGbeyRuVWxyd/H70ytJjU0Ceg==
Authentication-results: spf=none (sender IP is ) smtp.mailfrom=yakir.matusovsky@xxxxxxxxxxx;
Thread-index: AQHV8oUt3ByIqDmbbki/AKwT34kVxw==
Thread-topic: [Rohc] Issues with feedback-2 when dropping context on compressor

An update, we’ve tried running same scenario over prototype code with RoHC-2.3.1 and the problem is still there.

Regards,
Yakir

From: Rohc <rohc-bounces+yakir.matusovsky=mimomax.com@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> on behalf of Yakir Matusovsky <yakir.matusovsky@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Thursday, 5 March 2020 at 11:49 AM
To: Rohc <rohc@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, "didier@xxxxxxxxxxx" <didier@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: [Rohc] Issues with feedback-2 when dropping context on compressor

Experiencing an issue with RoHC 2.1.x code over a radio link, where if IPv4 pinging across a near end to the far end, after a reboot on the near end the compressor receives a malformed feedback from a far end decomp and seems that it can’t reduce its compression state, used optimistic mode,

rohc_comp.c:3108 rohc_comp_feedback_parse_opts()] malformed FEEDBACK-2: packet too short for 6-byte option 15, o
rohc_comp_rfc3095.c:961 rohc_comp_rfc3095_feedback_2()] malformed FEEDBACK-2: failed to parse options
rohc_comp_rfc3095.c:903 rohc_comp_rfc3095_feedback()] failed to handle FEEDBACK-2
rohc_comp.c:2004 __rohc_comp_deliver_feedback()] failed to deliver feedback: failed to handle FEEDBACK-2
rohc_comp.c:2101 rohc_comp_deliver_feedback2()] failed to deliver feedback item #1
rohc_comp.c:3108 rohc_comp_feedback_parse_opts()] malformed FEEDBACK-2: packet too short for 9-byte option 4, on
rohc_comp_rfc3095.c:961 rohc_comp_rfc3095_feedback_2()] malformed FEEDBACK-2: failed to parse options
rohc_comp_rfc3095.c:903 rohc_comp_rfc3095_feedback()] failed to handle FEEDBACK-2
rohc_comp.c:2004 __rohc_comp_deliver_feedback()] failed to deliver feedback: failed to handle FEEDBACK-2
rohc_comp.c:2101 rohc_comp_deliver_feedback2()] failed to deliver feedback item #1
rohc_comp.c:3108 rohc_comp_feedback_parse_opts()] malformed FEEDBACK-2: packet too short for 9-byte option 4, on
rohc_comp_rfc3095.c:961 rohc_comp_rfc3095_feedback_2()] malformed FEEDBACK-2: failed to parse options
rohc_comp_rfc3095.c:903 rohc_comp_rfc3095_feedback()] failed to handle FEEDBACK-2
rohc_comp.c:2004 __rohc_comp_deliver_feedback()] failed to deliver feedback: failed to handle FEEDBACK-2
rohc_comp.c:2101 rohc_comp_deliver_feedback2()] failed to deliver feedback item #1
rohc_comp.c:3108 rohc_comp_feedback_parse_opts()] malformed FEEDBACK-2: packet too short for 9-byte option 4, on
rohc_comp_rfc3095.c:961 rohc_comp_rfc3095_feedback_2()] malformed FEEDBACK-2: failed to parse options
rohc_comp_rfc3095.c:903 rohc_comp_rfc3095_feedback()] failed to handle FEEDBACK-2
rohc_comp.c:2004 __rohc_comp_deliver_feedback()] failed to deliver feedback: failed to handle FEEDBACK-2
rohc_comp.c:2101 rohc_comp_deliver_feedback2()] failed to deliver feedback item #1

The ping is stuck.

The product is about to go on 2.3.1 in future, however, could this be resolved in the current version mentioned?

Regards
Yakir

Follow ups

Re: Issues with feedback-2 when dropping context on compressor
From: Yakir Matusovsky, 2020-03-05