touch-packages team mailing list archive

[Brian Murray <brian@xxxxxxxxxx>]

** Description changed:

+ Test Case
+ ---------
+ 1) Edit a .crash file to have an UnreportableReason key and value e.g.
+    UnreportableReason: Your system is weird.
+ 2) sudo service whoopsie stop
+ 3) start whoopsie pointing to errors.staging.ubuntu.com e.g.
+    sudo CRASH_DB_URL=https://daisy.staging.ubuntu.com APPORT_REPORT_DIR=/var/crash/ whoopsie -f
+ 4) Put said .crash file in /var/crash/
+ 5) Put a corresponding .upload file in /var/crash/
+ 6) Observe whoopsie uploading the .crash file from the whoopsie log
+    [16:51:13] Reported OOPS ID 4ea43136-880e-11e5-828e-fa163e1893a8
+ 7) go to errors.staging.ubuntu.com/oops/$OOPS_ID
+ 8) verify the UnreportableReason appears there e.g.:
+    https://errors.staging.ubuntu.com/oops/4ea43136-880e-11e5-828e-fa163e1893a8
+ 
+ 
  In src/whoopsie.c we can see the following:
  
-     /* We would only want this to see how many bugs would otherwise go
-      * unreported: */
-     "UnreportableReason",
+     /* We would only want this to see how many bugs would otherwise go
+      * unreported: */
+     "UnreportableReason",
  
  The comment isn't exactly true.  apport uses the UnreportableReason key
  to include the following information:
  
-   "You have some obsolete package versions installed."
+   "You have some obsolete package versions installed."
  
  It'd be useful if this information was sent to the Error Tracker so that
  we can decide not to ask for a core dump from these crash reports. The
  "obsolete package versions" check is done by checking to see if the most
  recent available version of the package is installed, so if someone does
  not have -updates enabled then that pocket is not checked and "obsolete
  package versions" will not be present. This is desirable because the
  retracers will check to see if the package version is available from any
  pocket.
  
  So if we send UnreportableReason to the Error Tracker we can stop asking
  for core dumps and retracing crashes that will fail to retrace.
  
  However, the value for UnreportableReason is translated so this may not
  end up helping much.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Touch seeded packages, which is subscribed to whoopsie in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1382233

Title:
  whoopsie does not upload UnreportableReason field in crash reports

Status in whoopsie package in Ubuntu:
  Fix Released
Status in whoopsie source package in Precise:
  In Progress
Status in whoopsie source package in Trusty:
  In Progress
Status in whoopsie source package in Vivid:
  In Progress
Status in whoopsie source package in Wily:
  In Progress

Bug description:
  Test Case
  ---------
  1) Edit a .crash file to have an UnreportableReason key and value e.g.
     UnreportableReason: Your system is weird.
  2) sudo service whoopsie stop
  3) start whoopsie pointing to errors.staging.ubuntu.com e.g.
     sudo CRASH_DB_URL=https://daisy.staging.ubuntu.com APPORT_REPORT_DIR=/var/crash/ whoopsie -f
  4) Put said .crash file in /var/crash/
  5) Put a corresponding .upload file in /var/crash/
  6) Observe whoopsie uploading the .crash file from the whoopsie log
     [16:51:13] Reported OOPS ID 4ea43136-880e-11e5-828e-fa163e1893a8
  7) go to errors.staging.ubuntu.com/oops/$OOPS_ID
  8) verify the UnreportableReason appears there e.g.:
     https://errors.staging.ubuntu.com/oops/4ea43136-880e-11e5-828e-fa163e1893a8

  
  In src/whoopsie.c we can see the following:

      /* We would only want this to see how many bugs would otherwise go
       * unreported: */
      "UnreportableReason",

  The comment isn't exactly true.  apport uses the UnreportableReason
  key to include the following information:

    "You have some obsolete package versions installed."

  It'd be useful if this information was sent to the Error Tracker so
  that we can decide not to ask for a core dump from these crash
  reports. The "obsolete package versions" check is done by checking to
  see if the most recent available version of the package is installed,
  so if someone does not have -updates enabled then that pocket is not
  checked and "obsolete package versions" will not be present. This is
  desirable because the retracers will check to see if the package
  version is available from any pocket.

  So if we send UnreportableReason to the Error Tracker we can stop
  asking for core dumps and retracing crashes that will fail to retrace.

  However, the value for UnreportableReason is translated so this may
  not end up helping much.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/whoopsie/+bug/1382233/+subscriptions