← Back to team overview

ubuntu-appstore-developers team mailing list archive

Re: Summary: Early discussions about review process

 

Hey,

On 17.06.2013 15:36, Dave Morley wrote:
> If we are testing that the app is installable testing that it is
> runable is a 30seconds more work and can possibly be automated, ie
> start a vm on server, allow all ppas/package repos (however click is
> going to work), start app, sleep 20 seconds, does appname appear in ps
> aux, if true close app, sleep 20 seconds, does it appear in ps aux, if
> false publish app.  If any app fails the test, they are then viewed
> manually, so you need a system to ping you when one fails. :)

this might be possible, but would still take a while. I'll leave this
for somebody else to comment on it. :)


>> - App operates correctly - doesn’t scale, handle by user reviews
> 
> When you say handled by user reviews, who looks at the reviews to see
> if apps need removing?  Currently I don't think anyone is responsible
> for clearing application review issues from reviews.ubuntu.com
> currently, let alone looking to see if applications should be removed.

Very good question. Maybe it'd make sense to have some kind of regular
reports from the ratings&reviews database. Something like

 number of negative reviews in the last 24h  >
	critical percentage  * number of total comments

Not sure if that's a good early warning system, but we could try it out. :-)

Is that what everybody had in mind during the conversation?

Thanks in advance.

Have a great day,
 Daniel

-- 
Get involved in Ubuntu development! developer.ubuntu.com/packaging
Follow @ubuntudev on identi.ca/twitter.com/facebook.com/G+


Follow ups

References