yahoo-eng-team team mailing list archive

[eagle0407 <1831195@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Public bug reported:

Description
   ===========
  When one nova compute service manage multi hypervisors, disable the nova-compute service will prevent nova scheduler from choosing all the hypervisor it manages because the code in compute_filter.py :

  service = host_state.service
  if service['disabled']:
   LOG.debug("%(host_state)s is disabled, reason: %(reason)s",
       {'host_state': host_state,
        'reason': service.get('disabled_reason')})
   return False

  and i think this is not reasonable.

  One solution is to make each compute service manage only one
hypervisor, but this result more compute services.

   Steps to reproduce
   ==================

   Expected result
   ===============
   operator can disable individual hypervisor

   Actual result
   =============
   Disable one nova compute prevent nova scheduer choosing all the hypervisors it manages

   Environment
   ===========

   Logs & Configs
   ==============

** Affects: nova
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New


** Tags: hypervisor nova-compute scheduler

** Tags added: hypervisor

** Tags added: nova-compute scheduler

** Description changed:

- When one nova compute service manage multi hypervisors, disable the
- nova-compute service will prevent nova scheduler from choosing all the
- hypervisor it manages because the code in compute_filter.py :
+  Description
+    ===========
+   When one nova compute service manage multi hypervisors, disable the nova-compute service 
+   will prevent nova scheduler from choosing all the hypervisor it manages because the code 
+   in compute_filter.py :
  
- service = host_state.service
- if service['disabled']:
- 	LOG.debug("%(host_state)s is disabled, reason: %(reason)s",
- 			  {'host_state': host_state,
- 			   'reason': service.get('disabled_reason')})
- 	return False
+   service = host_state.service
+   if service['disabled']:
+    LOG.debug("%(host_state)s is disabled, reason: %(reason)s",
+        {'host_state': host_state,
+         'reason': service.get('disabled_reason')})
+    return False
  
- and i think this is not reasonable.
+   and i think this is not reasonable.
  
- One solution is to make each compute service manage only one hypervisor,
- but this result more compute services.
+   One solution is to make each compute service manage only one hypervisor, but this result 
+   more compute services.
+    
+ 
+    Steps to reproduce
+    ==================
+    
+    Expected result
+    ===============
+    operator can disable individual hypervisor
+ 
+    Actual result
+    =============
+    Disable one nova compute prevent nova scheduer choosing all the hypervisors it manages
+    
+    Environment
+    ===========
+   
+    Logs & Configs
+    ==============

** Description changed:

-  Description
-    ===========
-   When one nova compute service manage multi hypervisors, disable the nova-compute service 
-   will prevent nova scheduler from choosing all the hypervisor it manages because the code 
-   in compute_filter.py :
+ Description
+    ===========
+   When one nova compute service manage multi hypervisors, disable the nova-compute service will prevent nova scheduler from choosing all the hypervisor it manages because the code in compute_filter.py :
  
-   service = host_state.service
-   if service['disabled']:
+   service = host_state.service
+   if service['disabled']:
     LOG.debug("%(host_state)s is disabled, reason: %(reason)s",
         {'host_state': host_state,
          'reason': service.get('disabled_reason')})
-    return False
+    return False
  
-   and i think this is not reasonable.
+   and i think this is not reasonable.
  
-   One solution is to make each compute service manage only one hypervisor, but this result 
-   more compute services.
-    
+   One solution is to make each compute service manage only one
+ hypervisor, but this result more compute services.
  
-    Steps to reproduce
-    ==================
-    
-    Expected result
-    ===============
-    operator can disable individual hypervisor
+    Steps to reproduce
+    ==================
  
-    Actual result
-    =============
-    Disable one nova compute prevent nova scheduer choosing all the hypervisors it manages
-    
-    Environment
-    ===========
-   
-    Logs & Configs
-    ==============
+    Expected result
+    ===============
+    operator can disable individual hypervisor
+ 
+    Actual result
+    =============
+    Disable one nova compute prevent nova scheduer choosing all the hypervisors it manages
+ 
+    Environment
+    ===========
+ 
+    Logs & Configs
+    ==============

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Yahoo!
Engineering Team, which is subscribed to OpenStack Compute (nova).
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1831195

Title:
  disable one compute service will prevent scheduler  to choose the
  hypervisor the compute service manange

Status in OpenStack Compute (nova):
  New

Bug description:
  Description
     ===========
    When one nova compute service manage multi hypervisors, disable the nova-compute service will prevent nova scheduler from choosing all the hypervisor it manages because the code in compute_filter.py :

    service = host_state.service
    if service['disabled']:
     LOG.debug("%(host_state)s is disabled, reason: %(reason)s",
         {'host_state': host_state,
          'reason': service.get('disabled_reason')})
     return False

    and i think this is not reasonable.

    One solution is to make each compute service manage only one
  hypervisor, but this result more compute services.

     Steps to reproduce
     ==================

     Expected result
     ===============
     operator can disable individual hypervisor

     Actual result
     =============
     Disable one nova compute prevent nova scheduer choosing all the hypervisors it manages

     Environment
     ===========

     Logs & Configs
     ==============

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/nova/+bug/1831195/+subscriptions