yahoo-eng-team team mailing list archive

[Brian Haley <1833257@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Closing as no one has been able to work on this, please re-open if
necessary.

** Changed in: neutron
       Status: In Progress => Won't Fix

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Yahoo!
Engineering Team, which is subscribed to neutron.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1833257

Title:
  By default Horizon sets Firewall group admin state to False when user
  trying to set it true  Firewall always remains in DOWN state

Status in neutron:
  Won't Fix

Bug description:
  Create a openStack Firewall-V2 group by setting admin state to False through Horizon.
  Only openStack Horizon gives that option to set the Firewall group admin state to false not openstack cli command.

  Add  Firewall-V2 policy to the Firewall group. After adding  router
  port to Firewall group its status  remains in the DOWN state it is
  expected as admin state is set to False.

  But when admin-state is set to true it never comes into Active state
  and always remains in DOWN state.

  >Before Admin state is false

  Add port to the Firewall-V2  policy.

  [root@vioshim-l42jp6xt7m-vioshim-84bb866c4d-lw6wj /]# openstack firewall group show F2
  +-------------------+-------------------------------------------+
  | Field             | Value                                     |
  +-------------------+-------------------------------------------+
  | Description       |                                           |
  | Egress Policy ID  | None                                      |
  | ID                | b951672d-1c9a-41cf-b096-db574601d6e2      |
  | Ingress Policy ID | 1338b6c9-2f16-4e2b-8f9b-d876ec744a03      |
  | Name              | F2                                        |
  | Ports             | [u'3693155c-c07d-4e0b-8723-6f83acb85943'] |
  | Project           | 52e5cd63615243cd9439952c5214d0f7          |
  | Shared            | False                                     |
  | State             | DOWN                                      |
  | Status            | DOWN                                      |
  | project_id        | 52e5cd63615243cd9439952c5214d0f7          |
  +-------------------+-------------------------------------------+



  > after Admin state is set to true.

  
  [root@vioshim-l42jp6xt7m-vioshim-84bb866c4d-lw6wj /]# openstack firewall group show  b951672d-1c9a-41cf-b096-db574601d6e2
  +-------------------+-------------------------------------------+
  | Field             | Value                                     |
  +-------------------+-------------------------------------------+
  | Description       |                                           |
  | Egress Policy ID  | None                                      |
  | ID                | b951672d-1c9a-41cf-b096-db574601d6e2      |
  | Ingress Policy ID | 1338b6c9-2f16-4e2b-8f9b-d876ec744a03      |
  | Name              | F2                                        |
  | Ports             | [u'3693155c-c07d-4e0b-8723-6f83acb85943'] |
  | Project           | 52e5cd63615243cd9439952c5214d0f7          |
  | Shared            | False                                     |
  | State             | UP                                        |
  | Status            | DOWN                                      |
  | project_id        | 52e5cd63615243cd9439952c5214d0f7          |
  +-------------------+-------------------------------------------+

  Expected: Firewall group should come into ACTIVE state.
            Default option should remain same in both Horizon and Cli command.
               openstack Firewall group create set the admin state to true by default.

  Issue observed: Port update code  is not called during admin state
  change.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/neutron/+bug/1833257/+subscriptions