yahoo-eng-team team mailing list archive
-
yahoo-eng-team team
-
Mailing list archive
-
Message #96163
[Bug 2116930] [NEW] limit api does not return all limits
Public bug reported:
Greetings,
we implemented unified limits for nova and have limit api problems that
we are not able to list all created limits.
Here is a list of limits that we created for specific projects from the db point of view:
select * from `limit`;
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
| id | project_id | resource_limit | description | internal_id | registered_limit_id | domain_id |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
| 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 20 | 64a8a6a79ce943a8b95d8dbeaefcae70 | NULL |
| 7d5a62ce7e7d476d8fdb5ce6187228f4 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 30 | b4782b3c19844f0ca06e89d0f73da7ba | NULL |
| 095929916f744d3e9f3f196aa7251392 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 35 | 338c611d6982417cae9338b65053565d | NULL |
| 1c3966cd31e444d98a3d88180bab0f39 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 40 | 622b1c88be354028a7831272b320f5a7 | NULL |
| fe4e4f4d6cd7422183535f78f41c9dc7 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 45 | d0fab219f2864abb8a703f3774c92fa9 | NULL |
| d8d3179ee8e04d73af4fbcdbad47f464 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 1000 | NULL | 49 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| a1424e6943364b0186430c21a696af16 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 2097152 | NULL | 54 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| adee7610155143d9bb7a19b02285c8ef | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 10000 | NULL | 59 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| a8a9a114b848485683692f357727b770 | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 1000 | NULL | 64 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 0d6679dd917d40d4a104312da7b82e4f | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 4194304 | NULL | 69 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 072329989815445799baab16908fdc8c | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 10000 | NULL | 74 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| 7f2276a6f4bb4ec0b55fad73c7a3e1ae | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 1000 | NULL | 79 | 04d5791fcc714408a25c6f944a50086a | NULL |
| bf6cc20f77364f828074a5eda1cec6fe | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 1000 | NULL | 84 | 04d5791fcc714408a25c6f944a50086a | NULL |
| 8fe4e47c13b04423a9bcb8095a0b914d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 89 | 108fea16911e45d782853230fffd9cc7 | NULL |
| 2d7c7930fdfb413dae25ef257216575d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 94 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 9610a5187320450e8cb8729da08e5adc | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 99 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 33e8f7683adf4911ae9c7a10c93b235d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 104 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| 6c0af5e680bb4afb995214bf168d6f33 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 1500 | NULL | 109 | 108fea16911e45d782853230fffd9cc7 | NULL |
| 1102fe54443e4e76884847675f9e3976 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 3600 | NULL | 114 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 5438298578f841778a1ba69b4a7a4152 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 7864320 | NULL | 119 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 9049e24ffb254c9aa664241ff70811ec | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 20000 | NULL | 124 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
Using the openstack limit command as an admin user only returns limits related to the admin project:
openstack limit list
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
| ID | Project ID | Service ID | Resource Name | Resource Limit | Description | Region ID |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
| d8d3179ee8e04d73af4fbcdbad47f464 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:VCPU | 1000 | None | de-west-01 |
| a1424e6943364b0186430c21a696af16 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:MEMORY_MB | 2097152 | None | de-west-01 |
| adee7610155143d9bb7a19b02285c8ef | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:DISK_GB | 10000 | None | de-west-01 |
| 7f2276a6f4bb4ec0b55fad73c7a3e1ae | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:PCPU | 1000 | None | de-west-01 |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
Even specifying a project that is clearly inside the limit db table results in no output:
openstack limit list --project ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 --debug
RESP BODY: {"limits": [], "links": {"next": null, "self": "https://identity.openstack.***/v3/limits?project_id=ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00";, "previous": null}}
I tested the same with a token and curl where I have the exact same
result, I have no way to list all existing limits.
We are running keystone 2025.1 (27.0.0)
Thanks in advance!
EDIT:
Forgot to tell that using openstack limit show on a specific id out of the db works and shows the limit:
openstack limit show 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55
+----------------+----------------------------------+
| Field | Value |
+----------------+----------------------------------+
| description | None |
| domain_id | None |
| id | 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55 |
| project_id | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 |
| region_id | de-west-01 |
| resource_limit | -1 |
| resource_name | server_injected_files |
| service_id | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce |
+----------------+----------------------------------+
** Affects: keystone
Importance: Undecided
Status: New
** Description changed:
Greetings,
we implemented unified limits for nova and have limit api problems that
we are not able to list all created limits.
Here is a list of limits that we created for specific projects from the db point of view:
select * from `limit`;
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
| id | project_id | resource_limit | description | internal_id | registered_limit_id | domain_id |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
| 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 20 | 64a8a6a79ce943a8b95d8dbeaefcae70 | NULL |
| 7d5a62ce7e7d476d8fdb5ce6187228f4 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 30 | b4782b3c19844f0ca06e89d0f73da7ba | NULL |
| 095929916f744d3e9f3f196aa7251392 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 35 | 338c611d6982417cae9338b65053565d | NULL |
| 1c3966cd31e444d98a3d88180bab0f39 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 40 | 622b1c88be354028a7831272b320f5a7 | NULL |
| fe4e4f4d6cd7422183535f78f41c9dc7 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 45 | d0fab219f2864abb8a703f3774c92fa9 | NULL |
| d8d3179ee8e04d73af4fbcdbad47f464 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 1000 | NULL | 49 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| a1424e6943364b0186430c21a696af16 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 2097152 | NULL | 54 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| adee7610155143d9bb7a19b02285c8ef | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 10000 | NULL | 59 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| a8a9a114b848485683692f357727b770 | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 1000 | NULL | 64 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 0d6679dd917d40d4a104312da7b82e4f | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 4194304 | NULL | 69 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 072329989815445799baab16908fdc8c | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 10000 | NULL | 74 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| 7f2276a6f4bb4ec0b55fad73c7a3e1ae | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 1000 | NULL | 79 | 04d5791fcc714408a25c6f944a50086a | NULL |
| bf6cc20f77364f828074a5eda1cec6fe | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 1000 | NULL | 84 | 04d5791fcc714408a25c6f944a50086a | NULL |
| 8fe4e47c13b04423a9bcb8095a0b914d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 89 | 108fea16911e45d782853230fffd9cc7 | NULL |
| 2d7c7930fdfb413dae25ef257216575d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 94 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 9610a5187320450e8cb8729da08e5adc | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 99 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 33e8f7683adf4911ae9c7a10c93b235d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 104 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| 6c0af5e680bb4afb995214bf168d6f33 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 1500 | NULL | 109 | 108fea16911e45d782853230fffd9cc7 | NULL |
| 1102fe54443e4e76884847675f9e3976 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 3600 | NULL | 114 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 5438298578f841778a1ba69b4a7a4152 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 7864320 | NULL | 119 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 9049e24ffb254c9aa664241ff70811ec | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 20000 | NULL | 124 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
-
Using the openstack limit command as an admin user only returns limits related to the admin project:
- openstack limit list
+ openstack limit list
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
| ID | Project ID | Service ID | Resource Name | Resource Limit | Description | Region ID |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
| d8d3179ee8e04d73af4fbcdbad47f464 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:VCPU | 1000 | None | de-west-01 |
| a1424e6943364b0186430c21a696af16 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:MEMORY_MB | 2097152 | None | de-west-01 |
| adee7610155143d9bb7a19b02285c8ef | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:DISK_GB | 10000 | None | de-west-01 |
| 7f2276a6f4bb4ec0b55fad73c7a3e1ae | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:PCPU | 1000 | None | de-west-01 |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
-
Even specifying a project that is clearly inside the limit db table results in no output:
openstack limit list --project ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 --debug
RESP BODY: {"limits": [], "links": {"next": null, "self": "https://identity.openstack.***/v3/limits?project_id=ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00";, "previous": null}}
I tested the same with a token and curl where I have the exact same
result, I have no way to list all existing limits.
We are running keystone 2025.1 (27.0.0)
Thanks in advance!
+
+ EDIT:
+ Forgot to tell that using openstack limit show on a specific id out of the db works and shows the limit:
+ openstack limit show 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55
+ +----------------+----------------------------------+
+ | Field | Value |
+ +----------------+----------------------------------+
+ | description | None |
+ | domain_id | None |
+ | id | 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55 |
+ | project_id | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 |
+ | region_id | de-west-01 |
+ | resource_limit | -1 |
+ | resource_name | server_injected_files |
+ | service_id | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce |
+ +----------------+----------------------------------+
--
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Yahoo!
Engineering Team, which is subscribed to OpenStack Identity (keystone).
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/2116930
Title:
limit api does not return all limits
Status in OpenStack Identity (keystone):
New
Bug description:
Greetings,
we implemented unified limits for nova and have limit api problems
that we are not able to list all created limits.
Here is a list of limits that we created for specific projects from the db point of view:
select * from `limit`;
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
| id | project_id | resource_limit | description | internal_id | registered_limit_id | domain_id |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
| 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 20 | 64a8a6a79ce943a8b95d8dbeaefcae70 | NULL |
| 7d5a62ce7e7d476d8fdb5ce6187228f4 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 30 | b4782b3c19844f0ca06e89d0f73da7ba | NULL |
| 095929916f744d3e9f3f196aa7251392 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 35 | 338c611d6982417cae9338b65053565d | NULL |
| 1c3966cd31e444d98a3d88180bab0f39 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 40 | 622b1c88be354028a7831272b320f5a7 | NULL |
| fe4e4f4d6cd7422183535f78f41c9dc7 | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | -1 | NULL | 45 | d0fab219f2864abb8a703f3774c92fa9 | NULL |
| d8d3179ee8e04d73af4fbcdbad47f464 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 1000 | NULL | 49 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| a1424e6943364b0186430c21a696af16 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 2097152 | NULL | 54 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| adee7610155143d9bb7a19b02285c8ef | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 10000 | NULL | 59 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| a8a9a114b848485683692f357727b770 | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 1000 | NULL | 64 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 0d6679dd917d40d4a104312da7b82e4f | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 4194304 | NULL | 69 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 072329989815445799baab16908fdc8c | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 10000 | NULL | 74 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| 7f2276a6f4bb4ec0b55fad73c7a3e1ae | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | 1000 | NULL | 79 | 04d5791fcc714408a25c6f944a50086a | NULL |
| bf6cc20f77364f828074a5eda1cec6fe | 8b9a03f7e78b4644a15b41d75f31f542 | 1000 | NULL | 84 | 04d5791fcc714408a25c6f944a50086a | NULL |
| 8fe4e47c13b04423a9bcb8095a0b914d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 89 | 108fea16911e45d782853230fffd9cc7 | NULL |
| 2d7c7930fdfb413dae25ef257216575d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 94 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 9610a5187320450e8cb8729da08e5adc | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 99 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 33e8f7683adf4911ae9c7a10c93b235d | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 | 2147483647 | NULL | 104 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
| 6c0af5e680bb4afb995214bf168d6f33 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 1500 | NULL | 109 | 108fea16911e45d782853230fffd9cc7 | NULL |
| 1102fe54443e4e76884847675f9e3976 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 3600 | NULL | 114 | 707568b0c13e4afbade398f17ad13ea5 | NULL |
| 5438298578f841778a1ba69b4a7a4152 | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 7864320 | NULL | 119 | 327fa4b3ab6a46c09fc71b9bac197dfe | NULL |
| 9049e24ffb254c9aa664241ff70811ec | 4d382c3097a5423396f434e7e8d612b6 | 20000 | NULL | 124 | 988025c0422342a7bdf21e4b0ae62d25 | NULL |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------+-------------+-------------+----------------------------------+-----------+
Using the openstack limit command as an admin user only returns limits related to the admin project:
openstack limit list
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
| ID | Project ID | Service ID | Resource Name | Resource Limit | Description | Region ID |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
| d8d3179ee8e04d73af4fbcdbad47f464 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:VCPU | 1000 | None | de-west-01 |
| a1424e6943364b0186430c21a696af16 | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:MEMORY_MB | 2097152 | None | de-west-01 |
| adee7610155143d9bb7a19b02285c8ef | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:DISK_GB | 10000 | None | de-west-01 |
| 7f2276a6f4bb4ec0b55fad73c7a3e1ae | 36a72ce6ca87481bb911a50f6ae259d8 | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce | class:PCPU | 1000 | None | de-west-01 |
+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+----------------------------------+-----------------+----------------+-------------+------------+
Even specifying a project that is clearly inside the limit db table results in no output:
openstack limit list --project ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 --debug
RESP BODY: {"limits": [], "links": {"next": null, "self": "https://identity.openstack.***/v3/limits?project_id=ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00";, "previous": null}}
I tested the same with a token and curl where I have the exact same
result, I have no way to list all existing limits.
We are running keystone 2025.1 (27.0.0)
Thanks in advance!
EDIT:
Forgot to tell that using openstack limit show on a specific id out of the db works and shows the limit:
openstack limit show 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55
+----------------+----------------------------------+
| Field | Value |
+----------------+----------------------------------+
| description | None |
| domain_id | None |
| id | 94abb5603f9f4f83a690b709d1af1f55 |
| project_id | ccb16549f8694a6dbfe618a31cceeb00 |
| region_id | de-west-01 |
| resource_limit | -1 |
| resource_name | server_injected_files |
| service_id | ecd56230f05848e6a3bae263374c25ce |
+----------------+----------------------------------+
To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/keystone/+bug/2116930/+subscriptions
