desktop-packages team mailing list archive

[Bob Bib <882731@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Public bug reported:

Ubuntu 11.10 (amd64)
banshee 2.2.0-1ubuntu2

If a song is deleted from disk, this has no effect on the library:
Banshee will stay silent and simply not play that song listed in
library, so I need to manually find and remove non-existing items from
the library and re-import the music after some changes in my music
collection.

When I choose 'Rescan library' option from the menu, it has no effects
on the missing items, they still stay in the library.

Reaction on the missing items in the library should be neither silently
absent as in Banshee, nor so aggressive as in Rhythmbox which
automatically rescans the library for missing items on start-up.

I think, the optimal solution is to not enable the "missing items scan
on startup" by default, but to make a "Rescan library" button; after
library rescanning, the missing items should be moved to "Missing items"
section, where unneeded songs can be manually removed; on the next
rescan, songs from "Missing items" that have become available, should be
moved back to the library, the others should remain in "Missing items".

** Affects: banshee (Ubuntu)
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New

** Description changed:

- If a song is deleted from disk, this has no effect on the library, so
+ If a song is deleted from disk, this has no effect on the library:
  Banshee will simply not play that song listed in library, so I need to
  manually find and remove non-existing items from the library and re-
  import the music after some changes in my music collection.
  
  When I choose 'Rescan library' option from the menu, it has no effects
  on the missing items, they still stay in the library.
  
  Reaction on the missing items in the library should be neither silently
  absent as in Banshee, nor so aggressive as in Rhythmbox which
  automatically rescans the library for missing items on start-up.
  
  I think, the optimal solution is to not enable the "missing items scan
  on startup" by default, but to make a "Rescan library" button; after
  library rescanning, the missing items should be moved to "Missing items"
  section, where unneeded songs can be manually removed; on the next
  rescan, songs from "Missing items" that have become available, should be
  moved back to the library, the others should remain in "Missing items".

** Description changed:

  If a song is deleted from disk, this has no effect on the library:
- Banshee will simply not play that song listed in library, so I need to
- manually find and remove non-existing items from the library and re-
- import the music after some changes in my music collection.
+ Banshee will stay silent and simply not play that song listed in
+ library, so I need to manually find and remove non-existing items from
+ the library and re-import the music after some changes in my music
+ collection.
  
  When I choose 'Rescan library' option from the menu, it has no effects
  on the missing items, they still stay in the library.
  
  Reaction on the missing items in the library should be neither silently
  absent as in Banshee, nor so aggressive as in Rhythmbox which
  automatically rescans the library for missing items on start-up.
  
  I think, the optimal solution is to not enable the "missing items scan
  on startup" by default, but to make a "Rescan library" button; after
  library rescanning, the missing items should be moved to "Missing items"
  section, where unneeded songs can be manually removed; on the next
  rescan, songs from "Missing items" that have become available, should be
  moved back to the library, the others should remain in "Missing items".

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Desktop
Packages, which is subscribed to banshee in Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/882731

Title:
  library rescan functionality should be extended with missing items
  scan

Status in “banshee” package in Ubuntu:
  New

Bug description:
  Ubuntu 11.10 (amd64)
  banshee 2.2.0-1ubuntu2

  If a song is deleted from disk, this has no effect on the library:
  Banshee will stay silent and simply not play that song listed in
  library, so I need to manually find and remove non-existing items from
  the library and re-import the music after some changes in my music
  collection.

  When I choose 'Rescan library' option from the menu, it has no effects
  on the missing items, they still stay in the library.

  Reaction on the missing items in the library should be neither
  silently absent as in Banshee, nor so aggressive as in Rhythmbox which
  automatically rescans the library for missing items on start-up.

  I think, the optimal solution is to not enable the "missing items scan
  on startup" by default, but to make a "Rescan library" button; after
  library rescanning, the missing items should be moved to "Missing
  items" section, where unneeded songs can be manually removed; on the
  next rescan, songs from "Missing items" that have become available,
  should be moved back to the library, the others should remain in
  "Missing items".

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/banshee/+bug/882731/+subscriptions