kicad-developers team mailing list archive
Mailing list archive
Re: Annotation Epic/Geographic reannotation
Wayne Stambaugh <stambaughw@xxxxxxxxx>
Mon, 2 Mar 2020 14:52:24 -0500
addr=stambaughw@xxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQGiBEM0hxQRBAC2fNh3YOVLu1d5GZ0SbrTNldGiGnCJPLqzEnqFX9v6jmf33TMt6EmSLkl6 Wtfkoj0nVwKxcYmJkA8DX0QAokBkwNIzhSsBzQvthBLIk/5LnPVVKrEXOcL4mUyH1doKlkaE slgJozNa6Av+oavcvD02o1zJOloBbaHlNlyRt7fKswCgtIFlVjWggVH/15KfWk+Qo5JVPbME AIUBAQyL2OAx0n60AWec2WHnO9buHuG0ibtICgUMkE+2MRmYyKwYRdyVwGoIUemFuOyHp0AJ InX4T+vy2E7vkwODqjtMLfIoRkokW74Fi4nrvjlhOAw/vdq/twLbAmR9MOfPTpR4y7kQy1O2 /n+RkkRvh26vTzfbQmrH7cBJhk6aA/9Uwvu3E4zNJgHVZeS0HyWtmR1eOPPRbnkPgJTToX5O KMKzTJI/FX6kT7cFoCamitHrW3BJP4Dx+cMMsa47EGxqVTdbVJ4LjogsXTXxb+0Fn1u4zBdx x3Cer6O7+hqWy7zvpzeC6nSREjqDKa5CgHtv/GLm5uFPOmsjAsnHj2tlBrQmV2F5bmUgU3Rh bWJhdWdoIDxzdGFtYmF1Z2h3QGdtYWlsLmNvbT6IeAQTEQIAOBYhBOffs6CbblRzBkv33BtR cWlZ+CReBQJbFBS2AhsDBQsJCAcCBhUKCQgLAgQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEBtRcWlZ+CReMI8A nRbrLkzp7+c2f0vX7sfg4ICX8LAKAJ9uClo4uJajmZa5zZrL2nKdZlUwIrkCDQRDNIcxEAgA gCru+3/aOC6RCjpvYC72wY+d5SmHphC6yeiV2/mOumyt5MLo/Ps2GznZr11JspqFk5K/Zpvp MMLqqjDZ39+50a2iKRQFJ6NlK+hJWMmj6eJygQrCwYo3Gjc6CqfrqUv+8VSnf/i5sIZmtOVA 4ZjML18MuBvMSsNdVLFJd5HNnYb1iOECpvqdPVh/21LLCEw7MUUGGnHBhCrmk2aJe5hFmcSN g4ldBcXrgMQBwf7aMVoobXBMFDb/IENByXn0llB7Gr2IFMRmNS9/p8s/II1Yl2bTqyX4FSz8 cfn7C9KEz7faZ7wzAcpwHFC/zs3JoAjJ0IEKdNUpIwAlKMzT3CzctwADBQf/cxpG28MKyrqk nNmq/8LQLy+x6FSYXBLjxQz9BiBNYeesDZQ6J5UbL1mjpJzMa5tLZypPYo4bbGyR22hrbyDF K7m6AcVaMIJKl98g4ukMutFfAJyRDaREH5Zl/X1P4u1Z/yaAIy9mKaNbaK1/5djNJ5wCTFen TUgAp9xdc30kGkFDdLJFp5uxDY4P0vaZiZdjUCvDM3Zjv5IzpNOfxVqTUBQNUP/BnnKhkk0p DTD6s3X8S+D0rOtEBQ8K0cwERI/E8EFa8nj0TNw4e2MYGR8wg+SxqJ7z5f0zPY0bO6G9DDFB wYCqzzPWGqdAh9vA5971TAbPERtdFybhkurozp2SfYhJBBgRAgAJBQJDNIcxAhsMAAoJEBtR cWlZ+CResHUAniULLCWiT26ieRTl7N2vS6vBo/DuAJ4m7Ss/gyiW6ybTn1ctDXAUgm2QVQ==
Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/68.5.0
On 3/1/20 12:06 PM, Brian Piccioni wrote:
> I haven't had any feedback/comments regarding my merge request or
> Annotation suggestion for quite a few days now so I don't know whether
> my comments/pushes are being broadcast or people are simply busy working
> on other things.
> So, sorry for the spam.
> I just added this to the Annotations epic
> (https://gitlab.com/groups/kicad/code/-/epics/19) as I have been working
> on annotation. I would appreciate any feedback on the issues mentioned
> 1) No undo for annotation dialog
> Problem: eeSchema undo seems to be page confined.
> Fixing this would probably be a good idea but a lot of work and
> likely beyond my abilities
> at a this time. I can make a special "undo" stack for annotation as
> a stop gap.
I would reject any stop gap undo/redo code because it will just have to
be removed or refactored later. Either we fix the undo/redo code to
include all sheet changes or we live with what we have.
> 2) Annotate while adding is a WIP see
> See https://bugs.launchpad.net/kicad/+bug/1660134 for items 4 - 6.
> 4) Annotate selection
> I should be able to manage this
> 5) Anotate without a number
> 6) Annotate number only.
> 5 and 6 seem pretty straightforward to implement though there are
> filters on dialogs which will
> have to be fixed. There may be an issue with transfer between
> schematic and PCB
> (i.e. Update PCB to/from schematic) as well as geographic annotation
> from the PCB as error
> checking is done on all of these. I am working on a unified reference
> "splitter" for eeSchema and
> PCBNew to ensure consistency.
> My concern is that annotation seems pretty well woven into eeSchema,
> DRC, library editor, etc., and
> something will break if we do this. For example, having a reference
> with RK causes DRC to ask for
> annotation as does updating PCB from Schematic. If things break they
> can be fixed, but what if the
> breakage is only apparent on edge conditions? How can we test?
> 8) Subsheets don't match multi-unit element annotations. (lp:#1788976)
> I do not understand this
> 9) Implement more (and custom?) annotation schemes
> I have already coded prefixs to allow for IEE 200, etc.. One can then
> annotate sheet by sheet
> to give a prefix to each sheet. Alternatively we could add a sheet
> specific symbol/flag/notation
> which defines a prefix per sheet. I suspect that reannotating each
> sheet with a sheet prefix
> would meet most use cases.
> 10) Clear annotation does not work under MSW
> I cannot replicate this. The results I get are different from the
> video. It works fine for me.
> Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~kicad-developers
> Post to : kicad-developers@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~kicad-developers
> More help : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp