yahoo-eng-team team mailing list archive

[Ankur Gupta <ankur.gupta@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Public bug reported:

"glance member-create" CLI Shares a specific image with a tenant.

usage: glance member-create [--can-share] <IMAGE> <TENANT_ID>

Positional arguments:
  <IMAGE>      Image to add member to.
  <TENANT_ID>  Tenant to add as member

If I pass a non-existing tenant as <TENANT ID>, it also accept that and adds as a member of that image while it should raise
error as "No tenant with a name or ID of '-----' exists."

Below are the command execution logs-

$ keystone tenant-list
+----------------------------------+----------+---------+
|                id                |   name   | enabled |
+----------------------------------+----------+---------+
| a1c37cc595024369aa2124b50adaa0b8 |  admin   |   True  |
| 31dd5bdca08e4ce0b208ef618142875b | cephtest |   True  |
| 944ffc3c82f0444488eb7f61bc77bef0 |   demo   |   True  |
| ed34d901e2314ab6a93e01ebad44e445 | service  |   True  |
+----------------------------------+----------+---------+

$ glance image-list
+--------------------------------------+----------------------------+-------------+------------------+------------+--------+
| ID                                   | Name                       | Disk Format | Container Format | Size       | Status |
+--------------------------------------+----------------------------+-------------+------------------+------------+--------+
| 90368993-bd57-4b99-b371-98ff771b9c3f | ceph-test-image            | raw         | bare             | 13147648   | active |
| e3d88dcf-8c96-425e-b5eb-0d64c737d193 | ceph-test-snapshot         | raw         | bare             | 1073741824 | active |
| 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805 | ceph-test-yatin            | raw         | bare             | 13147648   | active |

$ glance member-create  8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805
a1c37cc595024369 --> with incomplete or wrong Tenant-ID

$ glance member-list  --image-id 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805
+--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+
| Image ID                             | Member ID        | Can Share |
+--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+
| 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805 | a1c37cc595024369 |           |
+--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+

** Affects: glance
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New

** Description changed:

  "glance member-create" CLI Shares a specific image with a tenant.
  
  usage: glance member-create [--can-share] <IMAGE> <TENANT_ID>
  
  Positional arguments:
-   <IMAGE>      Image to add member to.
-   <TENANT_ID>  Tenant to add as member
+   <IMAGE>      Image to add member to.
+   <TENANT_ID>  Tenant to add as member
  
- 
- If I pass a non-existing tenant as <TENANT ID>, it also accept that and adds as a member of that image while it should raise 
+ If I pass a non-existing tenant as <TENANT ID>, it also accept that and adds as a member of that image while it should raise
  error as "No tenant with a name or ID of '-----' exists."
  
  Below are the command execution logs-
  
  $ keystone tenant-list
  +----------------------------------+----------+---------+
  |                id                |   name   | enabled |
  +----------------------------------+----------+---------+
  | a1c37cc595024369aa2124b50adaa0b8 |  admin   |   True  |
  | 31dd5bdca08e4ce0b208ef618142875b | cephtest |   True  |
  | 944ffc3c82f0444488eb7f61bc77bef0 |   demo   |   True  |
  | ed34d901e2314ab6a93e01ebad44e445 | service  |   True  |
  +----------------------------------+----------+---------+
  
  $ glance image-list
  +--------------------------------------+----------------------------+-------------+------------------+------------+--------+
  | ID                                   | Name                       | Disk Format | Container Format | Size       | Status |
  +--------------------------------------+----------------------------+-------------+------------------+------------+--------+
  | 90368993-bd57-4b99-b371-98ff771b9c3f | ceph-test-image            | raw         | bare             | 13147648   | active |
  | e3d88dcf-8c96-425e-b5eb-0d64c737d193 | ceph-test-snapshot         | raw         | bare             | 1073741824 | active |
  | 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805 | ceph-test-yatin            | raw         | bare             | 13147648   | active |
  
+ $ glance member-create  8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805
+ a1c37cc595024369 --> with incomplete or wrong Tenant-ID
  
- $ glance member-create  8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805 a1c37cc595024369 --> with incomplete or wrong Tenant-ID
- 
- necadmin@nechldcst-PowerEdge-2950:~$ glance member-list  --image-id 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805 
+ $ glance member-list  --image-id 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805
  +--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+
  | Image ID                             | Member ID        | Can Share |
  +--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+
  | 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805 | a1c37cc595024369 |           |
  +--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Yahoo!
Engineering Team, which is subscribed to Glance.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1389618

Title:
  "glance member-create" CLI adds non existing member/tenant with image

Status in OpenStack Image Registry and Delivery Service (Glance):
  New

Bug description:
  "glance member-create" CLI Shares a specific image with a tenant.

  usage: glance member-create [--can-share] <IMAGE> <TENANT_ID>

  Positional arguments:
    <IMAGE>      Image to add member to.
    <TENANT_ID>  Tenant to add as member

  If I pass a non-existing tenant as <TENANT ID>, it also accept that and adds as a member of that image while it should raise
  error as "No tenant with a name or ID of '-----' exists."

  Below are the command execution logs-

  $ keystone tenant-list
  +----------------------------------+----------+---------+
  |                id                |   name   | enabled |
  +----------------------------------+----------+---------+
  | a1c37cc595024369aa2124b50adaa0b8 |  admin   |   True  |
  | 31dd5bdca08e4ce0b208ef618142875b | cephtest |   True  |
  | 944ffc3c82f0444488eb7f61bc77bef0 |   demo   |   True  |
  | ed34d901e2314ab6a93e01ebad44e445 | service  |   True  |
  +----------------------------------+----------+---------+

  $ glance image-list
  +--------------------------------------+----------------------------+-------------+------------------+------------+--------+
  | ID                                   | Name                       | Disk Format | Container Format | Size       | Status |
  +--------------------------------------+----------------------------+-------------+------------------+------------+--------+
  | 90368993-bd57-4b99-b371-98ff771b9c3f | ceph-test-image            | raw         | bare             | 13147648   | active |
  | e3d88dcf-8c96-425e-b5eb-0d64c737d193 | ceph-test-snapshot         | raw         | bare             | 1073741824 | active |
  | 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805 | ceph-test-yatin            | raw         | bare             | 13147648   | active |

  $ glance member-create  8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805
  a1c37cc595024369 --> with incomplete or wrong Tenant-ID

  $ glance member-list  --image-id 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805
  +--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+
  | Image ID                             | Member ID        | Can Share |
  +--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+
  | 8ead940a-6ee8-43db-b45d-8895c5c59805 | a1c37cc595024369 |           |
  +--------------------------------------+------------------+-----------+

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/glance/+bug/1389618/+subscriptions