yahoo-eng-team team mailing list archive

Thread
Date
[Bug 2073263] [NEW] property 'RESKEY:availability_zones' for volume types ignored by volume creation

To: yahoo-eng-team@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
From: Robbert Nijgh <2073263@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Tue, 16 Jul 2024 12:31:30 -0000
Reply-to: Bug 2073263 <2073263@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Sender: noreply@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Public bug reported:

Background example:
In this example I have 3 cinder availability zones(AZs): storage01, storage02 & storage03
I have 2 volume types: Ceph & NetApp

The volume type Ceph is available in all 3 AZs, however NetApp is only
available in storage02 and storage03.

With the OpenStack CLI it is possible to set which AZs a volume type is available in:
> openstack volume type set NetApp --availability-zone storage02,storage03
> openstack volume type show NetApp
+--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| Field              | Value                                                                         |
+--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| access_project_ids | b1593bc2d19e4b94ae815eec6f569d87                                              |
| description        |                                                                               |
| id                 | 575c147c-1a64-4674-bd8d-da8c98be9dba                                          |
| is_public          | False                                                                         |
| name               | NetApp                                                                |
| properties         | RESKEY:availability_zones='storage02,storage03', volume_backend_name='netapp' |
| qos_specs_id       | 120f04a0-65dd-4cce-aeaa-14abf7e30f05                                          |
+--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

Bug // missing feature:
When clicking 'CREATE VOLUME', you're shown the fill-in/select form for the creation of a volume(s). When the volume-type Ceph is selected, it shows all available AZs in the select-able Availablity Zone list.

However, when NetApp is selected, it also shows all available AZs in the
Availability Zone list. When a client/end-user selects this volume-type
with the storage01 AZ (which is not available in the volume type
property). It results in a ugly Error message, stating the AZ
'storage01' is invalid.

Expected result:
When a volume-type that has the property 'RESKEY:availability_zones' configured, is selected. It is expected for horizon to dynamically change the list of Availability zones in the volume create Form. So that clients/end-users arent able to see or select a AZ that does not have the volume-type.

** Affects: horizon
     Importance: Undecided
         Status: New


** Tags: cinder

** Description changed:

  Background example:
  In this example I have 3 cinder availability zones(AZs): storage01, storage02 & storage03
  I have 2 volume types: Ceph & NetApp
  
  The volume type Ceph is available in all 3 AZs, however NetApp is only
  available in storage02 and storage03.
  
  With the OpenStack CLI it is possible to set which AZs a volume type is available in:
  > openstack volume type set NetApp --availability-zone storage02,storage03
  > openstack volume type show NetApp
  +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  | Field              | Value                                                                         |
  +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  | access_project_ids | b1593bc2d19e4b94ae815eec6f569d87                                              |
  | description        |                                                                               |
  | id                 | 575c147c-1a64-4674-bd8d-da8c98be9dba                                          |
  | is_public          | False                                                                         |
  | name               | NetApp                                                                |
  | properties         | RESKEY:availability_zones='storage02,storage03', volume_backend_name='netapp' |
  | qos_specs_id       | 120f04a0-65dd-4cce-aeaa-14abf7e30f05                                          |
  +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  
- 
  Bug // missing feature:
  When clicking 'CREATE VOLUME', you're shown the fill-in/select form for the creation of a volume(s). When the volume-type Ceph is selected, it shows all available AZs in the select-able Availablity Zone list.
  
  However, when NetApp is selected, it also shows all available AZs in the
  Availability Zone list. When a client/end-user selects this volume-type
  with the storage01 AZ (which is not available in the volume type
  property). It results in a ugly Error message, stating the AZ
  'storage01' is invalid.
  
- 
  Expected result:
- When the volume-type that has the property 'RESKEY:availability_zones' configured. It is expected for horizon to dynamically change the list of Availability zones in the volume create Form. So that clients/end-users arent able to see or select a AZ that does not have the volume-type.
+ When a volume-type that has the property 'RESKEY:availability_zones' configured, is selected. It is expected for horizon to dynamically change the list of Availability zones in the volume create Form. So that clients/end-users arent able to see or select a AZ that does not have the volume-type.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Yahoo!
Engineering Team, which is subscribed to OpenStack Dashboard (Horizon).
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/2073263

Title:
  property 'RESKEY:availability_zones' for volume types ignored by
  volume creation

Status in OpenStack Dashboard (Horizon):
  New

Bug description:
  Background example:
  In this example I have 3 cinder availability zones(AZs): storage01, storage02 & storage03
  I have 2 volume types: Ceph & NetApp

  The volume type Ceph is available in all 3 AZs, however NetApp is only
  available in storage02 and storage03.

  With the OpenStack CLI it is possible to set which AZs a volume type is available in:
  > openstack volume type set NetApp --availability-zone storage02,storage03
  > openstack volume type show NetApp
  +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  | Field              | Value                                                                         |
  +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
  | access_project_ids | b1593bc2d19e4b94ae815eec6f569d87                                              |
  | description        |                                                                               |
  | id                 | 575c147c-1a64-4674-bd8d-da8c98be9dba                                          |
  | is_public          | False                                                                         |
  | name               | NetApp                                                                |
  | properties         | RESKEY:availability_zones='storage02,storage03', volume_backend_name='netapp' |
  | qos_specs_id       | 120f04a0-65dd-4cce-aeaa-14abf7e30f05                                          |
  +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+

  Bug // missing feature:
  When clicking 'CREATE VOLUME', you're shown the fill-in/select form for the creation of a volume(s). When the volume-type Ceph is selected, it shows all available AZs in the select-able Availablity Zone list.

  However, when NetApp is selected, it also shows all available AZs in
  the Availability Zone list. When a client/end-user selects this
  volume-type with the storage01 AZ (which is not available in the
  volume type property). It results in a ugly Error message, stating the
  AZ 'storage01' is invalid.

  Expected result:
  When a volume-type that has the property 'RESKEY:availability_zones' configured, is selected. It is expected for horizon to dynamically change the list of Availability zones in the volume create Form. So that clients/end-users arent able to see or select a AZ that does not have the volume-type.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/horizon/+bug/2073263/+subscriptions