kicad-developers team mailing list archive
-
kicad-developers team
-
Mailing list archive
-
Message #39831
Re: Zone hatch filling patch
-
To:
<kicad-developers@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
-
From:
Vesa Solonen <vesa.solonen@xxxxxxxx>
-
Date:
Wed, 20 Mar 2019 20:52:21 +0200
-
Autocrypt:
addr=vesa.solonen@xxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= mQGiBEiy9EERBAD82hFx3nitjEVNCtkuedqJkwrBgNRsQIsR4zmT0Oy1okWnkzSRyEZHkesA HQy5d5z1OAGSn8BHEL2tJdQKbOCRhEL21yj35T81euDhD3q7pAxrJwwYz5wAyJpZ6ejMGG/g WOrsn5YpdkpR7RxdQ8GUAf7okUoQDemWNY9F8ftZ4wCg+cTF1WmXVPhzKBwy5GVMpTfQehcD /REoeVu4bwm2wTOQpkbnYdR7jJ8XyaAhZVpciWkrm0EH3ES7WhVDmaXzWb8gThzKjurnth6U s4nV7o9vG06sMDzf2siu/Ugbn/QZ1HW9lw2GeXBxwdSbctKiKOukTGNyb2xHN9upETAh9b6f vhNa0nlk+k4kuzvilMmuFSNFZ23HA/4r6kEfa16uK3oR5GQScvIojo95b3LgY2KsrFD6A0b0 61YLZusEB6gIiZ/DcJ+FQy8hQ6u04AmOOXwrneCfluzJFGhaHwOEJj9jwEQN2JMqgjHuMD+v 99Vph+Lzdm9UGOodPKGJ1JL3YyY9QYHj4IedTmDngJaI/2aRB/pgbB2NZbQkVmVzYSBTb2xv bmVuIDx2ZXNhLnNvbG9uZW5AYWFsdG8uZmk+iGIEExECACIFAlFZRuoCGwMGCwkIBwMCBhUI AgkKCwQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEHdUiFKgf4oRqVYAniu9/5XXglIeOd9v5exITDQXvm+jAJ9C 8EANjzQECWHh2YoE8nziX++VSrkCDQRIsvRGEAgA2v+TJXKtFv5TFtqy2egg0ARXX0i8+LtR tPtsXOCWUN51sSX8/1o23MPSzynMJNOsZ8yMEU7I9dDpEnZLAcaBGNrxj6V69uM1m4aAyds6 Qqwm+/nyBDz0zwQwayQjypqRahNTzH9cjIbXOJElh7otGvfI/8PBKCWzu6t/DjiM2+azFTod ADR8w/VXtSmoz5l+ouqJbHKE3xsNFFWnUbfit3EgGrpq16GYFNKm4+h8DIGyvz4YycB2Dmuo Aq+toOUeiIzH1GYe2pwjVzLVG+8x6kU/DRl7Qzst8P+eX4uMSfdepqUVIvYO00+vvYuL9Dkf qiz2lzhuTy+uUmlwvE8A6wADBQf9FD+wb0OWOlF7rG4f3DmdHmKQIXunFy64khfXh4NnCmJs pOfCQ9I+cw3vTeX9UwOHtBKFgUkt10lXYSoaaf7cXG7pTUTUKuy8IZeVd1e91WYqedTGYo9p I99mPP8q5mQFN4sV/pyYycyx8DREm7VMuprjAsoeZ6db6ZW+oweI6GkztCtXdPl4Ui84FSS/ CbSrXIoG9WkXz5DyHrfcEJpbYPMkY+ISnENlt5od/UdD+QlnqP907EJQhnBnftSmyrGzPx3M zno3kDGBwzbmy7HRBFs4dTfFbgZnp1JJNbfStDtNlbgO3mIeHDG4J6shTNe/Bg2mEauj7I/d pMnflWmkKIhJBBgRAgAJBQJIsvRGAhsMAAoJEHdUiFKgf4oRLjcAn19oVj+nNWXC9SRamlTc Nfp99bByAKD1R/uGemuAaJz3A46tUaEbVQ7Fww==
-
In-reply-to:
<12d08228-dacc-d336-57f4-62ca79005769@gmail.com>
-
Openpgp:
preference=signencrypt
-
User-agent:
Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/60.5.1
Wayne Stambaugh kirjoitti 20.3.2019 klo 20.27:
> thing I did notice was that the hatched zone filling appears to leave
> really small cutouts in some cases (see attached image). I know there
> is no setting for this but maybe we should use the "Minimum width"
> setting to removed excessively small cutouts as well as copper areas.
> I'm not sure what users are going to expect here but it's something to
> think about.
I would suggest that filled mode is applied whenever there is a partial
hatch opening. Obviously the smarter "correct" mode will result form the
rounding radius, e.g. the 2*radius defines the smallest opening
dimension. Small sharp corners are very bad for processing as they etch
and wash with difficulty. So there will be more ionic contaminants on
the board under the solder mask and possible corrosion and isolation
problems.
-Vesa
References