← Back to team overview

lubuntu-desktop team mailing list archive

Re: LXDM or Lightdm ?


Aloha oukou,

I agree with what Julian said about LightDM, on all mentioned
(dis)advantages. But the advantages should outweigh the disadvantages, as
Ubuntu and Xubuntu even have way more devs hanging around then Lubuntu.
Every error or bug we encounter we can put on launchpad and hopefully will
get sorted by one of the others. When we've got time to spare, we could
solve it ourselves of course and send our patch as solution.

So to recap, I'm pro on the switch.

With metta,

Chris Druif

On Thu, Jun 9, 2011 at 03:33, Ian Gilfillan <launchpad@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>wrote:

> Julien, just to clarify, LightDM uses 3.2Mb and LXDM 2.3 and not the other
> way around? This seems a trivial difference.
> You've mentioned before that support is important for a DM as it needs to
> be tested across many different configurations. LightDM seems far more
> active than LXDM, and in spite of being newer you say it's already more
> complete.
> I'd say go for the change - if there is a showstopper, or one gets
> introduced later, it should be relatively easy to revert. Also, if
> maintenance is being shared with Ubuntu (as opposed to being done by them),
> it should be possible to stop any issues being introduced that will
> negatively affect Lubuntu.
> The main risk seems to be one of bloat as LightDM gets more heavily
> developed, but LightDM was launched with the purpose of supporting LXDE
> (although not exclusively, like LXDM), so I'd feel confident about
> switching.
> --
> Ian Gilfillan
> www.greenman.co.za
> On 09/06/2011 00:26, Yorvyk wrote:
>> On Wed, 08 Jun 2011 20:39:42 +0200
>> Julien Lavergne<gilir@xxxxxxxxxx>  wrote:
>>  Hi,
>>> I'm a bit late for that, but it still time to discuss such topic.
>>> LightDM [1] will be the next display manager for Ubuntu, and probably
>>> Xubuntu (maybe Kubuntu also !). It will replace GDM which have a tight
>>> dependency on GNOME.
>>> LightDM has the advantage to split the greeter (the UI part) and the
>>> core (which do all the black magic for users, consolkit etc ...). You
>>> can build a greeter which use GTK only, Qt, Webkit etc ... It's also
>>> heavily developed this cycle.
>>> Last cycle I tested LightDM, but found that it was not ready. Also, LXDM
>>> is now in a good shape. I tested it briefly on Oneiric, and it seems in
>>> better shape now, and with RAM usage similar to LXDM (3.2 vs 2.3 Mb)
>>> To summarize :
>>> Advantages:
>>> * More complete than LXDM
>>> * Maintenance shared with Ubuntu and Xubuntu
>>> * Heavily developed
>>> Disadvantages :
>>> * New and less tested in Lubuntu than LXDM
>>> * Dependant to Ubuntu team for changes : we are not free to modify the
>>> DM, and it's possible that Ubuntu team introduce a change which
>>> indirectly impact others flavors (remember Ubiquity changes for disk
>>> requierement last cycle)
>>> IMO, if items I mentioned at the UDS are managed by LightDM [2], we can
>>> try to switch for this cycle. If later in the cycle we discover that
>>> there are problems, we can still switch again to LXDM.
>>> What do you think ?
>>> Regards,
>>> Julien Lavergne
>>> [1] : https://wiki.ubuntu.com/LightDM
>>> [2] : https://blueprints.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+spec/desktop-o-lightdm
>>>  I've been running Ubuntu Oneiric with lightdm for a while and it appears
>> to behave it's self OK.
>> Having had a bit of a read about it I don't see an advantage in either,
>> from a user's point of view, and I'm a bit lost with the technical
>> (dis)advantages.
>> A few thoughts.  With the change to GTK3 and the potential problems to be
>> resolved with that, are we adding another headache for the few competent
>> devs we have.
>> Or would having Lightdm give us one less problem, as others in the Ubuntu
>> community would be dealing with it and we wouldn't have to worry about lxdm
>> either.
>> Would sticking with what we know be better as lxdm doesn't have any real
>> problems and performs the function for which it is intended.
> _______________________________________________
> Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~lubuntu-desktop
> Post to     : lubuntu-desktop@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~lubuntu-desktop
> More help   : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp

Follow ups