unity-design team mailing list archive

[Conscious User <conscioususer@xxxxxxxxx>]

Em 04-05-2012 05:36, Thorsten Wilms escreveu:
> A list like this without the noise would be very welcome.
>
> But a number of people would have to be on both lists, then, to see 
> all the input and for seeing who can be invited. That's more load, not 
> less, for at least a selected few who are all supposed to have some 
> more valuable things to do, given their qualification.
>
> Creating yet another place also feels like a retreat.
>
> If moderation, how about switching this list to initially-moderated? 
> Emails of new subscribers would either be allowed to the list, or 
> moderators would write replies stating the reason for rejection 
> (ideally in the most constructive, patient and friendly manner – thus 
> not a job for me –, with pointers to relevant past discussions).
>
> Newcomers would be switched to direct-to-list after 2 or 3 "good" 
> emails. The reading and following-rules challenged could be put back 
> to moderated, or even disinvited.
>
> A little quiz could be used as hurdle to subscription ;)

This sounds like a better and more scalable approach.

If Launchpad supports everything that Thorsten is proposing,
I definitely prefer moderation over the creation of another list.