← Back to team overview

ubuntu-phone team mailing list archive

Re: Landing team 02.04.13

 

Le 02/04/2014 21:36, Jamie Strandboge a écrit :
On 04/02/2014 11:16 AM, Didier Roche wrote:

On the blocker list:
** Music/Calendar bug (Qt event look stopping when the device is suspend) (Saviq)
Discussion is happening and work is ongoing while discussing with upstream. Was
set as a blocker while whitelisted on the previous promotion blocker.

It's not clear from this email if this issue would block promotion. I think the
agreement before was to let it in once so 5.2 would be unblocked, and then make
it a blocker. This made sense to me at the time I expressed my opinions on this
bug, but I think things have changed sufficiently since then. This bug is making
us ask some deep questions about how we do things. From my perspective, the
point of the promotion blocker for a known regression we let in is to make sure
the regression gets fixed and is not forgotten. At least from the email threads,
it seems clear that many people are involved in fixing this bug and it won't be
forgotten. Therefore, imho this should no longer be a promotion blocker.

My two cents and if I misunderstood something, I apologize.

I completely agree with you and I raised that. I've been told that QA will make those kind of decisions, not the landing team (to whitelist/vote on blockers). I'm just reporting the current status until the QA team are answering (I guess they are waiting on all the other blockers to be gone and no new to enter to talk on that one).

Cheers,
Didier


References