unity-design team mailing list archive

[Niklas Rosenqvist <niklas.s.rosenqvist@xxxxxxxxx>]

Ed Lin I apologize for the rudeness of my latests replies. The reason behind
it was that I was getting frustrated of you just pointing out weaknesses
without any proposed solutions except for doing it as Gnome Shell.  As I
said about the feature request am I new to this community and wasn't sure
about how to proceed. My mockup was a design sketch as mockups are, not the
end product. I hope we can leave that behind us now that we have a problem
identified: some people prefer a window centric environment and some an
app-centric, how are we supposed to please both groups? I myself prefer the
window centric model and I hope we can make Unity more versatile for the two
philosophies.

"A good interface could combine both and gradually
exposes additional features depending on the skills and expectations
 of its user. But really that's for another thread."

Can't we continue the discussion here since we are already arguing here?

"I've made a mockup of my own. The goal was to improve the difference
between running and not running applications without introducing other
changes or preventing the implementation of a hidden application
indicator.
before|after with two different designs (FF/Thunderbird and banshee at
 the bottom):"

So what exactly is the mockup showing? Is the wider background box showing
the currently focused application and FF and TB are hidden? Please provide
us with further explaining of what is what in the mockup since the left
launcher is already a configurable option in CCSM. One thing I noted
immediately is the lack of the subtle background boxes in the right
launcher. I don't think that is a good idea since those boxes gives
uniformity to the launcher between the different states when a squared icon
set isn't used. I don't think it would work well with the default icon set.