← Back to team overview

kicad-developers team mailing list archive

Re: GitLab migration


On 2019-10-14 16:09, Ian McInerney wrote:


Great work so far.

I was noticing as you were testing migrating the issues that our @names in the text seem to not transfer well. In one of the issues just now (the pcbnew segfault issue #228 [2]) it pulls in a different user for Seth whenever @seth is mentioned, and also for my name. Do you think it would be possible to do two things with the message text: 1) Replace the @name usage for the most common people with their GitLab user (this would require us to know all of them and have a map between name and user). This should also be case insensitive, since we don't always seem to capitalize names. 2) Escape the @name usage in other cases (maybe add a space between the @ and the name?).

At the very least we should probably escape them so we don't randomly mention unrelated people in all our issues.

On the topic of labels, I was doing some research and if we can get the OSS license for GitLab I think we can turn the Launchpad status and priority into scoped labels [1]. The nice thing about those is only one label per scope can be applied to an issue at a time, and adding a new label to an issue automatically removes the old one. I think we could define scopes such as
priority::{wishlist, low, medium, etc...}
status::{new, confirmed, in progress, as designed, fix committed, etc...}

By doing this I think it is nice and obvious what the open/close status of the bug is (instead of just having open/close).

I'll second Ian's suggestion that the priorities and status both get labels. I'd like to see Heat map to GitLab's weight. You can't really search much with weight in GitLab (no range operators that I can find), so it seems mostly useful for sorting after you get the results.

I think we'll need to figure out how to deal with our version information in KiCad not being nicely formatted for markdown. The blockquote for variable indents is readable but distracting. Maybe we can get it into a block like:
<summary>KiCad Version Info</summary>
<pre>All the details here</pre>

Overall, this is great!  Looking forward to the move.


Follow ups